Progress in Nuclear Energy 124 (2020) 103343
Available online 8 April 2020
0149-1970/© 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Progress in Nuclear Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/pnucene
Isotopic depletion calculation with generalized perturbation theory in
subcritical systems driven by an external neutron source
P.K. Taipe
∗
, F.C. Silva, A.C.M. Alvim
Nuclear Engineering Program - COPPE, Federal University of Rio de Janeiro, Av. Horacio Macedo 2030, 21941-914, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Subcritical system
Burnup calculation
Isotopic depletion calculation
Generalized perturbation theory
ABSTRACT
Generalized Perturbation Theory (GPT) is used with the aim of proposing a perturbation method for isotopic
depletion calculations. Changes in nuclide densities over time induce variations in the neutron flux and these
lead to changes in reaction rates present in the evolution matrix. The proposed perturbation method treats
these reaction rates as integral quantities and changes in these integral quantities as perturbations coming
from changes in nuclide densities with fuel burnup. This method is applied to a subcritical system driven by
an external neutron source. The results obtained by perturbation method show good agreement with the direct
calculation. Considering that only a 1D problem was tested, other problems treating more energy groups and
2 or 3 spatial dimensions should be done in order to fully validate the method.
1. Introduction
The methods of Perturbation Theory have been used in Reactor
Physics, since the pioneering work of Wigner (1945). Since then, sev-
eral other works have been developed with the objective of extending
the applicability of this theory to treat other Reactor Physics problems.
Among these works are those that gave rise to the so-called Gener-
alized Perturbation Theory (Usachev, 1964; Lewins, 1965; Gandini,
1967 and 1983). One of the applications of perturbation theory is, for
example, in isotopic depletion calculations (Williams, 1979; Silva and
Thomé, 1987; Downar, 1992; Kallfelz et al., 1977).
The isotopic composition of the reactor core has to be monitored
during the fuel burnup, because heavy, high radiotoxicity elements are
produced that accumulate as minor actinides (MA) and fission products
(FP) in the nuclear waste at the end of the fuel cycle.
Hybrid systems driven by an external neutron source (Rubbia et al.,
1995; Bowman et al., 1992; Stacey, 2007) have been proposed to close
the open (or once-through) fuel cycle (IAEA, 2018), to get rid of accu-
mulation of MA and FP. These systems tackle this problem by burning
MA and FP, and then reusing them together with fresh fuel during
refueling. Two main examples of these systems are the Accelerator
Driven Systems (ADS) (Gandini and Salvatores, 2002; MYRRHA, 1998)
and the Fusion–Fission Reactor Systems (FFRS) (Mauer et al., 2004;
Hoffman and Stacey, 2002; ITER, 1985).
In this work, our main interest is to develop a method able to
calculate nuclide densities using GPT, but without neglecting the prod-
ucts of perturbed quantities, contrary to what is presently done up
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: ptorres@nuclear.ufrj.br (P.K. Taipe), fernando@nuclear.ufrj.br (F.C. Silva), alvim@nuclear.ufrj.br (A.C.M. Alvim).
to now. In this sense, this method is a novel approach for treating
reactor physics problems with GPT. For this, a perturbation method is
proposed that treats reaction rates appearing in the evolution matrix
as integral quantities. During the fuel cycle, nuclide densities change,
inducing variations in the neutron flux which leads to variations in
the integral quantities (or perturbations in the integral quantities), that
are then determined applying GPT. Thus, in this method the iterative
process of calculating the neutron flux is replaced by a GPT expression
to obtain new reaction rates directly. Once the new reaction rates are
found, the evolution matrix can be constructed for each time step,
the depletion equations can be solved at each time, using the method
proposed by Alvim et al. (2010), and finally, the nuclide densities can
be obtained at the end of the burnup cycle.
The method proposed by Alvim et al. (2010) to solve isotopic
depletion equations, is part of the CNFR code (Portuguese acronym
for National Code of Reactor Physics) (Silva et al., 2010; Prata et al.,
2013; Heimlich et al., 2016 and 2018).
This work is organized as follows. In Section 2 we describe the
equations for isotopic depletion calculation. In Section 3 we formulate
the perturbation method which will be used to make the depletion
calculation. In Section 4 we show the applicability of our proposed
method to a simple case. Finally, in Section 5 we present a summary
and our conclusions.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pnucene.2020.103343
Received 7 November 2019; Received in revised form 22 March 2020; Accepted 23 March 2020