ERNST MAYR LIBRARY AND ARCHIVES OF THE MUSEUM OF COMPARATIVE ZOOLOGY, HARVARD UNIV.
Pioneer of molecular evolution who campaigned against biological racism.
R
ichard Lewontin was a groundbreak-
ing geneticist, best known for bringing
molecular tools into evolutionary
biology and for his advocacy against
the use of science to rationalize struc-
tural inequity. Lewontin and his collaborators
revealed how natural selection acts to shape
variation, exploring its effect on genes, groups
and individuals. Moving between mathemat-
ical and statistical analysis, fieldwork and
laboratory experiment, they set the course
of molecular population genetics. Lewontin
saw no place for his discipline in attempts to
explain why “the children of oil magnates tend
to become bankers, while the children of oil
workers tend to be in debt to banks”.
Lewontin’s sometimes controversial
critiques of science, often from a Marxist
perspective, inspired new thinking on the rela-
tionship between science, politics and society.
He was an outspoken critic of sociobiology and
adaptationism (the idea that all traits evolved
as adaptations of an organism to its environ-
ment). He despised the use of biology to justify
racist ideology, especially with regard to IQ
testing. His celebrated essay ‘The spandrels
of San Marco and the Panglossian paradigm’,
written with his colleague Stephen Jay Gould
(Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B. 205, 581–598; 1979) skew-
ered, among other things, a “reliance upon
plausibility alone as a criterion for accepting
speculative tales”. Lewontin has died aged 92.
Richard Lewontin was born into an upper-
middle-class Jewish family in New York City,
and originally studied biology at Harvard
University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, in the
early 1950s. At the time, Harvard had no faculty
member specializing in genetics, so Lewontin
studied with a visitor, Leslie C. Dunn, from
Columbia University in New York City. Dunn
persuaded Lewontin to join the Columbia
laboratory of Theodosius Dobzhansky, then
the most influential evolutionary geneticist
in the world. Lewontin adopted Dobzhansky’s
investigation of the nature of selection and its
impact on the variability of natural and lab-
oratory populations. He completed his PhD
in 1954.
That year, Lewontin joined the faculty at
North Carolina State University in Raleigh.
Here, he focused primarily on mathematical
population genetics and worked with Ken-Ichi
Kojima on genetic linkage, the tendency of
neighbouring genetic sequences to be inher-
ited together. After periods at the University
of Rochester, New York, and the University of
Chicago, Illinois, he spent the rest of his career
at Harvard.
During his time at Rochester in the early
1960s, attempts to study genetic variation
in natural populations were approaching an
impasse. On a visit to the University of Chicago,
Lewontin met Jack Hubby, who was adapting
the biochemical technique of electropho-
resis (which separates molecules by charge
and size) to study the fruit fly Drosophila.
They realized that detecting small differences
between proteins could provide a new means
of measuring genetic variability.
Lewontin moved to the University of
Chicago and, with Hubby, published two
landmark papers (Genetics 54, 577–594 and
595–609; 1966), which opened the way for the
widespread application of electrophoresis
and marked the beginning of molecular pop-
ulation genetics. These papers also revealed
higher than expected amounts of genetic var-
iability, addressing a long-standing dispute
about whether natural selection maintains
genetic variability in natural populations.
In 1984, Martin Kreitman, working between
Lewontin’s and Walter Gilbert’s laboratories
at Harvard, brought DNA sequencing to bear
on this question.
In Chicago in the 1960s, Lewontin became
increasingly politically active, speaking out
against racial discrimination, the Vietnam War
and economic inequality. His fervent convic-
tions led him to renounce his election to the
US National Academy of Sciences, because
of its support for secret war research. With
ecologist Dick Levins and support from the
Ford Foundation, he assembled a group to
investigate the role of capital in agricultural
research, such as the development of hybrid
crop plants. Lewontin and Levins’s collabora-
tion also led to a series of essays on biology
and society from a Marxist perspective, pub-
lished later as The Dialectical Biologist (1985)
and Biology Under the Influence (2007). Like
his critiques of sociobiology, many of these
essays treated science as politics, arguing
against reductionism and determinism that
favoured biological explanations of complex
biosocial phenomena.
Lewontin also spoke up against biological
racism. His landmark paper ‘The Apportion-
ment of Human Diversity’ (in Evolutionary Biol-
ogy Vol. 6 (eds T. Dobzhansky et al.) Springer,
1972) found more variation within so-called
‘racial groups’ than between them, leading
him to argue that such distinctions had no
genetic basis. When biological arguments for
race were again put forward in the context of
mental testing in the 1980s, he opposed them
on scientific and social grounds, notably in Not
in Our Genes: Biology, Ideology, and Human
Nature (1984), co-authored with Steven Rose
and Leon Kamin, and reissued in 2017 during
the administration of US President Donald
Trump. He continued to publish in this realm
for decades.
Lewontin described himself as a pessimis-
tic biologist. He was a profoundly critical
thinker, willing to challenge the scientific and
philosophical foundations of his discipline as
well as their social, cultural and political con-
sequences. His research and reflections set an
agenda for generations of biologists, philoso-
phers of biology and socially engaged scholars.
In keeping with his socialism, he disliked
biography and its celebration of the individual.
When, in 1997, I asked him how I should write
about his life, he pulled out of his desk a list of
every graduate student, postdoc and visitor at
his laboratory — more than 100 people — and
said I should write about all of them. They were
his greatest source of pride as a scientist.
Michael R. Dietrich spent a sabbatical in
Lewontin’s laboratory in 1997. He has co-edited
many books about iconoclastic biologists,
and is a professor in the Department of History
and Philosophy of Science at the University of
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA.
e-mail: MDietrich@pitt.edu.
Richard C. Lewontin
(1929–2021)
Nature | Vol 595 | 22 July 2021 | 489
Obituary ©2021SpringerNatureLimited.Allrightsreserved.