C.L. Saw et al. 2011. Int. J. Vehicle Structures & Systems, 3(1), 28-35
International Journal of
Vehicle Structures & Systems
Available online at www.ijvss.maftree.org
ISSN: 0975-3060 (Print), 0975-3540 (Online)
doi:10.4273/ijvss.3.1.04
© 2011. MechAero Foundation for Technical Research & Education Excellence
28
Disc Brake Squeal Suppression Through Chamfered and Slotted Pad
Saw Chun Lin
a,b
, Choong Chee Guan
a
, Abd Rahim Abu Bakar
c
, Mohd Rahimi Jamaluddin
c
, Wan
Mohd Musyris Wan Harujan
c
, and Badri Abd Ghani
c
a
Politeknik Premier Ungku Omar, Jalan Raja Musa Mahadi,
31400 Ipoh, Perak, Malaysia.
b
Corresponding Author, Email: clsaw78@gmail.com
c
Automotive Engineering Department, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia,
81310 UTM Skudai, Malaysia.
ABSTRCT:
For decades, it has been a challenging task for brake engineers to reduce or totally eliminate squeal that emanates
from brake systems. Despite the large number of proposals that have been implemented in tackling disc brake squeal,
very few solutions are totally effective to reduce or suppress it. This paper presents an approach to tackle disc brake
squeal through chamfered and slotted pad. A three-dimensional FE model of an actual disc brake system is developed.
The baseline FE model is first simulated using complex eigenvalue and transient analysis to predict squeal and
compared to the squeal tests data obtained in the brake dynamometer. A reasonable correlation is found between these
results. Then, three different pad modifications are proposed, simulated and tested. It is shown that pad with chamfers
and diagonal slot can totally suppress squeal both in prediction and squeal test.
KEYWORDS:
Disc brake; Finite element; Pad modifications; Squeal; Complex eigenvalue; Dynamic transient; Brake dynamometer
CITATION:
C.L.Saw, C.G. Choong, A.R. Abu Bakar, M.R. Jamaluddin, W.M.M.W. Harujan, and B.A. Ghani. 2011. Disc brake
squeal suppression through chamfered and slotted pad, Int. J. Vehicle Structures & Systems, 3(1), 28-35. doi:10.4273/
ijvss.3.1.04
1. Introduction
Over decades, brake squeal has been a major issue to
vehicle manufacturers due to high warranty payouts.
Akay [1] stated that the warranty claims due to the noise,
vibration and harshness (NVH) issues including brake
squeal in North America alone were up to one billion US
dollars a year. Similarly, Abendroth and Wernitz [2]
noted that many friction material suppliers had to spend
up to 50 percent of their engineering budgets on the
NVH issues. It is well accepted that brake squeal is due
to friction - induced vibration or self-excited vibration
via a rotating disc. Brake squeal frequently occurs at
frequency above 1 kHz [3] and is described as sound
pressure level (SPL) above 78 dB [4]. Brake squeal has
been studied since 1930’s by many investigators through
experimental, analytical and numerical methods in an
attempt to understand, to predict and to prevent squeal
occurrence.
In recent years, the finite element (FE) method has
become the preferred method in studying brake squeal.
The popularity of FE analysis is due to the inadequacy of
experimental methods in predicting squeal at the early
stage in the design process. Moreover, FE analysis can
potentially simulate any changes made on the disc brake
components much faster and easier than experimental
methods [5]. With advances in computing technology,
more complex and complete FE models can be easily
generated and analyzed in quick turn-around time.
Nowadays the complex eigenvalue analysis has
become a preferred method to study brake squeal
compared to the dynamic transient analysis. Although
complex eigenvalue analysis [6-10] is the standard
methodology used in theoretical studies of brake squeal,
the transient analysis [10-14] is gradually gaining
popularity.
Chen [15] provided comprehensive guidelines to
suppress and eliminate squeal occurrence which includes
optimization of the damping, minimizing the impulsive
excitation and reducing the modal coupling. These three
guidelines have been implemented by many researchers
and thought to be essential for squeal reduction
approaches. Structural modifications have been a
favored means for achieving improved squeal
performance. For instance, Ishihara et al. [16] proposed a
method for reducing low-frequency disc brake squeal.
The fixed type, four opposed piston, disc brake was used
in their experiments. Changing rotor shape and material
were confirmed experimentally able to reduce the squeal.
Dunlap et al. [17] provided general solutions for every
categories of disc brake noise. In order to address low
frequency squeal, they proposed to decouple the caliper
and the disc modes where the disc material was changed
from gray cast iron to dampen iron. For high frequency
squeal, they increased the brake rotor stiffness to reduce
squeal propensity. They also observed that the brake pad
geometry and contact pressure had significant effect on
brake squeal.