Advances in Social Sciences Research Journal – Vol.4, No.3
Publication Date: Feb. 25, 2017
DoI:10.14738/assrj.43.2766
Garcia-Vázquez, A. I. (2017) .Indigenous Medical Tradition and Biomedical Tradition: A Historical Relation of Hegemony. Advances
in Social Sciences Research Journal, 4(3) 201-214
Copyright © Society for Science and Education, United Kingdom 201
Indigenous Medical Tradition and Biomedical Tradition: A
Historical Relation of Hegemony
Arlene Iskra García Vázquez
Researcher of Escuela Nacional de Estudios Superiores
Unidad León Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México
Blvd.UNAM 2011, Predio El Saucillo y El Potrero, Comunidad de los Tepetates
León, Gto. C.P.37684
ABSTRACT
The indigenous medical tradition is a system of knowledge, practices and beliefs about
health-illness process, used by many social groups in Mexico, which has prevailed in a
context marked by the epistemic, social and political hegemony of the biomedical
tradition, a situation that has shaped its historical development, has impeded its
recognition and appraisal as an effective and legitimate way to attend the health-illness
process, and has been excluded from the official medicine. The above is the result of a
historical process of long duration, which has its origins in the colonial era and was
favored by the epistemic supremacy of science. This work analyzes the established
relations, during the Spanish colonial era, between the indigenous and the Western
medical traditions, to understand how that led to epistemic, social, political and
institutional exclusion of the indigenous medical tradition. The historical stages of this
study were established to identify the major events in the hegemony relationships
among both traditions, which were analyzed based on the concepts of hegemony and
tradition. The conclusion is that the hegemony relationships between the biomedical
tradition and the indigenous medical tradition are the result of a historical and dynamic
process of selection, reinterpretation and redefinition of cultural elements of the
indigenous medical tradition, which involved the imposition of modern western culture’s
concept of the world and of the epistemic criteria of science, as well as the establishment
of institutions responsible of the control and regulation of the indigenous medical
practice.
Keywords: Indigenous medical tradition, Biomedical tradition, Hegemony, New Spain
INTRODUCTION
Since ancient times human beings have developed knowledge, practices, and explanations
about health and disease, which have been systematized and structured in medical systems.
These medical systems are part of broader cultural traditions whose ontological and
epistemological principles establish the context in which that knowledge, practices and
explanations are understandable and meaningful (Osorio, 2001; Campos, 2000).
In Mexico many medical traditions coexist; two of them are the biomedical tradition and the
indigenous medical tradition. The first one is the expression of scientific and technological
advances and was developed within the framework of modern Western culture, a culture
established on the exaltation of reason as the basis of all knowledge and the domain of nature
as well as the actions and human behaviors, including social, economic and political
organization.
The second tradition was configured from the worldview of the indigenous people that existed
before the Spanish conquest, the Aztecs, Nahuas, and Mayans. What today is known as the