Official Journal of
the British Blood Transfusion Society
Transfusion Medicine | LETTER TO THE EDITOR
Risk of Rh (D) alloimmunisation after Rh (D) positive platelet
transfusions in patients undergoing haematopoietic stem cell
transplantation
Dear Sir,
Transfusion of Rh (D) positive blood products to Rh (D) neg-
ative patients is not a rare practice in blood banks and depends
largely on Rh (D) negative blood products availability. Platelets
(PLTs) do not carry Rh antigens but PLT concentrates can be
contaminated by red blood cells, mainly if they are obtained from
whole-blood by bufy coat system (Bartley et al, 2009). Alloim-
munisation rates against D and other Rh antigens caused by PLT
transfusions is variable and ranges from 0 to 18.7% according to
published studies (Shaz & Hillyer, 2011). To our knowledge there
is no specifc data of Rh (D) alloimmunisation in patients under-
going haematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) receiv-
ing Rh (D) positive PLT transfusions. Tese patients are severely
immunocompromised, so is expected there would be a trend to
lower rate of alloimmunisation.
We retrospectively reviewed the clinical and transfusion
records of patients who underwent HSCT in our hospital for
a 14 year-period (2000–2013). Platelet concentrates were pre-
pared from whole-blood donations (WBD) according to the
bufy coat method by the Regional Transfusion Centre. Only
a small percentage of platelets (7%) were from a single donor
apheresis. Te antibody screen test (IAT) to detect anti-D was
performed in the automated system ORTHO Autovue Innova
using the gel test (Ortho Clinical Diagnostics, High Wycombe,
UK). Sera of patients with positive tests were tested for speci-
fcity using panels of RBC with known antigens (Ortho Clinical
and Diagnostics, Diamed and Makropanel). Inclusion criteria
were as follows: to have a negative IAT before transplantation
and to have performed another IAT at least 14days afer hos-
pital discharge, to receive HSCT from Rh (D) negative donors.
Tus, 47 patients were available for analysis: 27 men and 20
female, median age 50.6 years (range: 22·8–69·0), 29 patients
underwent autologous HSCT and 18 received and allogeneic
HSCT. Te 47 patients analysed received a median of 3 Rh (D)
positive PLT transfusions (range: 1–49).
Two patients both diagnosed of multiple myeloma who
underwent autologous HSCT developed anti-D (4·2%). One
Correspondence: Pilar Solves, Transfusion Service, Hematology Unit, Blood Bank, Hospital Universitari I Politècnic La Fe, Avda de Fernando Abril
Martorell, 106, Valencia 46026, Spain.
Tel.: 00 34 96 341 12 99; fax: 00 34 96 124 62 01; e-mail: solves_pil@gva.es
patient developed anti-D + anti-E 11 days afer one Rh (D)
positive WBD PTL transfusion. Tis patient was a woman and a
secondary immunologic response can not be excluded. Another
patient developed anti-D 10 months afer transfusion of nine Rh
(D) positive platelet concentrates (six WBD and three apheresis
PLTs).
Cid et al. (2002) have communicated absence of alloimmu-
nisation in a small series of 22 Rh (D) negative haematologic
patients transfused with Rh (D) positive PLTs. However, in a
larger study including 1014 immunocompetent and immuno-
suppressed Rh (D) negative patients, these authors have found
3·8% patients developing anti-D afer Rh (D) positive PLT trans-
fusions (Cid et al., 2011). Our analysis show similar results also
in immunosuppressed patients undergoing HSCT. On the other
hand, in a recent study O’Brien et al. (2014) have reported the
lack of immunisation in 130 Rh (D) negative patients trans-
fused with Rh (D) positive apheresis platelets. Te type of trans-
fused PLTs seems to be key to explain the diferences among
studies: whole-blood-derived platelets have a greater quantity of
red blood cells and therefore higher risk of alloimmunisation
(O’Brien et al., 2014) as compared with apheresis platelets (Shaz
& Hillyer, 2011). In conclusion, our results show that transfusion
of WBD Rh (D) positive PLTs produce anti-D alloimmunisation
even in patients that are severe immunocompromised, as those
receiving an HSCT.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
P. S. and N C. designed the study and wrote the paper, I. Gomez
and R. Hernani collected and analysed the data, and G. F. S. and
M. A. S. analysed the data and critically reviewed the paper.
P. Solves, N. Carpio, I. Gómez, R. Hernani, G. F. Sanz
& M. A. Sanz Transfusion Service, Hematology Unit, Hospital
Universitari I Politècnic La Fe, Valencia, Spain
First published online 4 March 2015
© 2015 British Blood Transfusion Society doi: 10.1111/tme.12179