The Debate on Pension Systems: The
Paradigmatic Cases of Chile and Spain
By XABIER ARRIZABALO MONTORO*, MARIO DEL ROSAL
†
and
F. JAVIER MURILLO ARROYO
‡
ABSTRACT. This article is focused on pension systems in the light of two
case studies that are antagonistic within the capitalist economy. On
the one hand, the Spanish pension scheme, based on the principle of
intergenerational solidarity, was achieved by the working-class after
decades of struggle. It constitutes the backbone of the Spanish social
security system, thanks to the creation and development of indirect
and deferred wages. On the other hand, the Chilean pension scheme,
first imposed by the Pinochet dictatorship, is based on a funded
system and private management. It rejects the principle of solidarity
and, therefore, it makes impossible the construction of a decent
pension structure. The comparison of the Spanish and the Chilean
pension systems can be expressed in just one revealing fact: while the
average pension in Spain is 79 percent of the last salary earned,
benefits in Chile barely reach 33 percent for male workers and 25
percent for female workers. The analysis of both cases is framed in
American Journal of Economics and Sociology, Vol. 78, No. 1 (January, 2019).
DOI: 10.1111/ajes.12262
© 2019 American Journal of Economics and Sociology, Inc.
*Professor at the Complutense University of Madrid (UCM) since 1993. Director of the
Instituto Marxista de Economía (IME). Co-Director of Research Group in Political
Economy Capitalism and Uneven Development. Director of Continuous Training Degree
Critical Analysis of Capitalism: Marxist Method and His Application to the Research of
Current Global Economy (UCM). Author of Capitalism and World Economy and numer-
ous other books and articles. Participant in many international congresses. Supervisor
of 15 doctoral theses. PhD in Economics. Other degrees in Planning, Public Policies and
Development, and Sociology. Email: xam@ccee.ucm.es
†
Adjunct Professor at the Complutense University of Madrid (UCM). Author of several
articles and chapters about the European economy, Marxist economics, and monetary the-
ory. Researcher at the Instituto Marxista de Economía. PhD in Economics (UCM) and a de-
gree in Politics (National University of Distance Education, UNED). Email: mariodel@ucm.es
‡
Adjunct Professor at the Complutense University of Madrid (UCM). Author of Marxist
Analysis of the “Spanish Miracle” (2018, Maia, Madrid). Published several articles about
income distribution and wages. Researcher at the Instituto Marxista de Economía. PhD
in Economics Email: fjmurillo@ccee.ucm.es