Russian Chemical Bulletin, International Edition, Vol. 69, No. 11, pp. 2073—2081, November, 2020 2073
Published in Russian in Izvestiya Akademii Nauk. Seriya Khimicheskaya, No. 11, pp. 2073—2081, November, 2020.
1066-5285/20/6911-2073 © 2020 Springer Science+Business Media LLC
Metal—ligand bond dissociation energies in the Ni, Pd, and Pt complexes
with N-heterocyclic carbenes: efect of the oxidation state of the metal (0, +2)
A. V. Astakhov, S. B. Soliev, and V. M. Chernyshev
M. I. Platov South-Russian State Polytechnic University,
132 ul. Prosveshcheniya, 346428 Novocherkassk, Russian Federation.
E-mail: chern13@yandex.ru
A DFT study was carried out of how the nature of metal, the oxidation state of the metal
(0 and +2), as well as the structures of N-heterocyclic carbene (NHC) and other ligands influ-
ence the heterolytic dissociation energies of the metal—ligand bond in the complexes M-NHC
(M = Ni, Pd, Pt). It was shown that a change in the oxidation state of the metal can be followed by
a considerable change in the M—NHC bond dissociation energy (up to nearly 21 kcal mol
–1
),
which is also strongly influenced by the ligand in the trans-position to NHC.
Key words: N-heterocyclic carbenes, coordination compounds, nickel, palladium, platinum,
bond dissociation energies, catalysis.
Nickel, palladium, and platinum complexes with
N-heterocyclic carbenes (NHC) are widely used as homo-
geneous catalysts.
1—6
They are also intensively studied as
luminescent materials
7—9
and cancer drugs.
10—12
Wide
use of metal complexes with NHC (M-NHC) is underlain
by higher stability of such systems compared to other types
of homogeneous catalysts since the M—NHC bond is very
strong.
1,2,13
However, M-NHC complexes can decompose
in solutions due to dissociation of the М—NHC bond,
which often occurs in rather mild conditions.
14—20
Dis-
sociation of the metal—ligand bond is of great importance
for catalysis and other practical applications because it
usually causes deactivation of catalysts
6,21—23
or changes
in the nature of active centers and in the mechanism
of catalysis.
24—27
Contrary to this, elimination of auxili-
ary ligands is often necessary to activate the catalyst,
M-NHC.
16
Thus, the catalytic properties of complexes M-NHC
depend strongly on their ability to break down with hetero-
lytic dissociation of the metal—ligand bond. Therefore,
the heterolytic bond dissociation energy (BDE),
28
which
can be calculated by quantum chemistry methods, is often
used to predict the catalytic properties of complexes.
29—31
To date, both experimental and theoretical BDE values
have been determined for various complexes M-NHC.
32—40
For instance, the influence of (i) the structure of the
NHC ligand on the M—NHC bond dissociation energies
(BDE
M—NHC
) in complexes with Ni
32,34,37
and Pd
36,37,39,40
and (ii) halide ligands on the BDE in complexes
Pd
II
-NHC
39
were studied. Steric factors, especially, bulky
substituents at nitrogen atoms of the NHC ligands afect
strongly the BDE
M—NHC
values.
29,30
However, it should
be noted that the oxidation state of the metal usually
changes in the course of catalysis and these changes can
influence the stability of the metal—ligand bonds. For
instance, the catalytic cycles of the cross-coupling, hydro-
genation, and СН-activation reactions very often involve
interconversions of the intermediates M
0
-NHC and
M
II
-NHC.
1—4
Therefore, prediction of catalytic activity
and stability of complexes requires taking account of the
mutual influence of the oxidation state of the metal and
the nature of the NHC ligand and other ligands on the
BDE values. It is commonly accepted that reduction of
the complexes M
II
L (L is ligand) to M
0
L considerably
reduces their thermodynamic stability.
41
However, it was
shown that BDE
Ni—NHC
in the Ni
0
-NHC complexes can
be higher than in the Ni
II
-NHC complexes with the same
NHC ligands.
35
Note that systematic studies of the efect
of the oxidation state of the metal on the metal—ligand
BDE have not been reported as yet.
In this work we used the density functional quantum
chemical calculations to study the joint efect of the oxida-
tion state of the metal (0 and +2) and the nature of the
NHC ligand and other ligands on the metal—ligand BDE
in the Ni, Pd, and Pt complexes belonging to the abundant
structure types (NHC)M
0
L and (NHC)M
II
(X)
2
L, where
NHC = 1,3-dimethylimidazol-2-ylidene, 1,3-dimethyl-
benzimidazol-2-ylidene, 1,4-dimethyl-1,2,4-triazol-5-
ylidene; X = Cl
–
, Br
–
, I
–
; L = Py, NHC, I
–
.
Calculation Methods
Calculations were carried out within the framework of the
density functional theory (DFT) using the Gaussian-09 pro-
gram.
42
To choose the optimum computational method, the most
often used DFT methods including PBE1PBE, B3LYP,