LASER-PLASMA ACCELERATION MODELING APPROACH IN THE
CASE OF ESCULAP PROJECT
V. Kubytskyi
†
, C. Bruni, K. Cassou, V. Chaumat, N. Delerue, D. Douillet, S. Jenzer,
H. Purwar, K. Wang, LAL,CNRS/IN2P3, Universite Paris-Saclay, Orsay, France
Rui Prazeres, CLIO/LCP, Orsay, France,
Elsa Baynar, Moana Pittman, CLUPS, Orsay, France
David Garzella, CEA/IRFU, Gif-sur-Yvette, France
J. Demailly, O. Guilbaud, S. Kazamias, B. Lucas, G. Maynard, O. Neveu, D. Ros,
CNRS LPGP Univ Paris Sud, Orsay, France
Abstract
Objective of ESCULAP project is the experimental study
of Laser-Plasma Acceleration (LPA) of relativistic electron
bunch from photo-injector in 9 cm length plasma cell [1].
In parallel, numerical tools have been developed in order
to optimize the setup configuration and the analysis of the
expected results. The most important issue when dealing
with numerical simulation over such large interaction dis-
tances is to obtain a good accuracy at a limited computing
cost in order to be able to perform parametric studies. Re-
duction of the computational cost can be obtained either
by using state-of-the-art numerical technics and/or by intro-
ducing adapted approximation in the physical model. Con-
cerning LPA, the relevant Maxwell-Vlasov equations can
be numerically solved by Particle-In-Cell (PIC) methods
without any additional approximation, but can be very com-
putationally expensive. On the other hand, the quasi-static
approximation [2], which yields a drastic reduction of the
computational cost, appears to be well adapted to the LPA
regime. In this paper we present a detailed comparison of
the performance, in terms of CPU, of LPA calculations and
of the accuracies of their results obtained either with a highly
optimized PIC code (FBPIC [3]) or with the well known
quasi-static code WAKE [3]. We first show that, when con-
sidering a sufficiently low charge bunch for which the beam
loading effect can be neglected, the quasi-static approxima-
tion is fully validated in the LPA regime. The case of a
higher bunch charge, with significant beam loading effects,
has also been investigated using an enhanced version of
WAKE, named WAKE-EP. Additionally, a cost evaluation,
in terms of used energy per calculation, has been done using
the multi-CPU and multi-GPU versions of FBPIC.
INTRODUCTION
The laser parameters for ESCULAP project are : max
power of 50 TW, waist of 50.5 μm, duration of 38.2 fs, a re-
duced potential a
0
= 0.7 and a wavelength λ
0
= 0.8 μm . An
electron bunch is injected at the entrance of the plasma with
a charge Q, a transverse rms size σ
r
= 10.0 μm, a longitudi-
nal rms size σ
z
= 5.0 μm, a normalised emittance 1 μm, and
an average energy of 10 MeV with a rms dispersion of 0.5 %.
The plasma cell has a length of 9 cm with a uniform electron
†
kubytsky@lal.in2p3.fr
density of 2 × 10
17
cm
-3
. The laser focal plane is placed
4 cm after the entrance of the plasma, the focusing zone
being used to compress the electron bunch before maximal
acceleration in order to reduce the emittance and the disper-
sion in energy [1, 4]. Numerical studies of the injection and
acceleration of low charge bunch was performed in [1,4]
with quasi-static code WAKE. In the present paper we char-
acterise acceleration of Q = 1-30 pC e- bunch in order to
determine the importance of beam loading effect, which is
the influence of the field generated by the bunch charge and
current. In-depth study of the beam loading effect for LPA
of an injected bunch was performed in [5] at Q=30pC but at
much higher electron energy and laser intensities.
The PIC simulations of LPWA were performed with the
FBPIC code using cylindrical grids with azimuthal decompo-
sition and dispersion-free field solver [3]. The calculations
have been done on CPU / GPU and in cluster environment
using a moving window with the boosted frame technique,
which allows to greatly speed up the PIC simulation.
NUMERICAL MODELING
Computational Domain Parameters
In our PIC simulation, the moving window has a longi-
tudinal size of 120 μm, the number of grid points being
4000, which leads to Δz ≈ λ
0
/30. Its radial size is 600 μm,
which is 3 times the waist of the laser at the entrance of the
target. The number of radial cells is 600 and the number of
macro-particles per cell is 24. Numerical convergence of
our simulation was checked on one calculation with a much
larger grid of 6000x1500 cells. For the Wake calculations
a similar moving window is used, however, thanks to the
envelope approximation, the number of longitudinal cells is
only 800.
Benchmarking
In Table 1 we present the average computing time for cal-
culating 9 cm propagation in plasma using either WAKE-EP
or FBPIC with a boosted-frame Lorentz factor of 5 . In
case of FBPIC, we checked multi-CPU using only OpenMP
with 48 cores or MPI-OpenMP with 7x20 cores. GPU cal-
culations were also performed using two Nvidia Tesla V100
GPU. Without boosted frame the FBPIC simulation is 20
times longer. Simulation on GPU in boosted frame takes
10th Int. Particle Accelerator Conf. IPAC2019, Melbourne, Australia JACoW Publishing
ISBN: 978-3-95450-208-0 doi:10.18429/JACoW-IPAC2019-THPGW059
MC3: Novel Particle Sources and Acceleration Techniques
A22 Plasma Wakefield Acceleration
THPGW059
3723
Content from this work may be used under the terms of the CC BY 3.0 licence (© 2019). Any distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s), title of the work, publisher, and DOI