JOURNAL OF GEOGRAPHY IN HIGHER EDUCATION, 2017
VOL. 41, NO. 4, 590–607
https://doi.org/10.1080/03098265.2017.1331424
Emotional masking and spill-outs in the neoliberalized
university: a feminist geographic perspective on mentorship
Fem-Mentee Collective*: Alison L. Bain
a
, Rachael Baker
a
, Nicole Laliberté
b
,
Alison Milan
a
, William J. Payne
a
, Léa Ravensbergen
b
and Dima Saad
c
a
Department of Geography, York University, Toronto, Canada;
b
Department of Geography, University of Toronto
Mississauga, Mississauga, Canada;
c
Department of Anthropology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada
ABSTRACT
This paper addresses the emotional dimensions of academic
mentorship from a student mentee perspective and contributes
to an emerging literature on geographies of emotion in higher
education. It presents a pedagogical practice of self-refexive
co-mentorship – self-peer-ceptive feminist mentoring – and deploys
it methodologically to analyze three biographical narratives. From
diferent student mentee vantage points, these narratives reveal
how the scales of the body, the family, and the nation are interwoven
within the geopolitical and manifest within mentoring relationships.
We argue that self-peer-ceptive feminist mentorship allows people
at diferent academic career stages to share personal experiences of
navigating the academy as a means to challenge institutional systems
of power. Our argument answers three questions: How and why do
we express and manage our emotions in mentoring relationships?
What spatial scales are invoked through our emotional experiences
and with what implications? How are diferent power structures
embedded in the requirements, practices, successes, and failures of
emotional management? Our discussion highlights how emotional
masking and spill-outs are tools to navigate the emotional terrain
of the neoliberalized academy. We conclude that self-peer-ceptive
feminist mentoring can unsettle the structural hierarchies that require
a “masking” of feelings for the sake of professional distance.
Introduction
Tis paper is inspired by “Toward mentoring as feminist praxis: strategies for ourselves and
others,” published in the Journal of Geography in Higher Education by six feminist geogra-
phers (Moss et al., 1999) who provide a notable critique of the long tradition of informal
mentoring in the academy. Moss et al. (1999, p. 413) remind us, “we need to develop widely
based mentoring strategies” rooted in “self-mentoring,” suggesting that we are our own best
mentors – that “we must remember and refect on our own experiences, think for ourselves,
and counsel ourselves as taking on the role of our own, most trusted guide” (p. 424). Tey
KEYWORDS
Mentoring; emotions;
self-peer-ceptive; feminism;
neoliberalized university
ARTICLE HISTORY
Received 27 May 2016
Accepted 23 January 2017
© 2017 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
CONTACT Alison L. Bain abain@yorku.ca
*The authors’ names are listed alphabetically.