Nanostructured Li Ion Insertion Electrodes. 2. Tin Dioxide Nanocrystalline Layers and
Discussion on “Nanoscale Effect”
P. R. Bueno,* E. R. Leite, T. R. Giraldi, L. O. S. Bulho jes, and E. Longo
Interdisciplinary Laboratory of Electrochemistry and Ceramics, Department of Chemistry,
Federal UniVersity of Sa ˜ o Carlos, C. Postal 676, 13565-905 Sa ˜ o Carlos, SP, Brazil
ReceiVed: February 27, 2003; In Final Form: June 6, 2003
Relaxation processes occurring during electroinsertion into pure SnO
2
and electrochromic SnO
2
/Sb were
interpreted on the basis of frequency-dependent response models. Within the framework of the classic theory
of porous electrodes, the results indicated that, in the case of nanosized particle-based electrodes, the overall
kinetic aspects of the insertion process can be controlled by the transport of ionic and electronic species in
the liquid and solid phases, respectively. Therefore, if both the electronic and ionic transport are fast in both
the solid and liquid phases, or if the state-of-charge is high, a relaxation process corresponding to the insertion
of Li
+
in specific sites inside the nanosized particles is clearly identifiable, as foreseen by the model discussed
in part 1. As a result, in the SnO
2
/Sb samples, we have successfully separated the frequency of slow charging
of transport effects due to the nonfaradaic capacitance-related process from that of faradaic related capacitances,
because these two processes do not overlap and can, in such specific situations, be separated in complex
capacitance diagrams. Moreover, our interpretation of the results indicates that the participation of a large
amount of inserted charge in the Sb-doped sample is possible due to the “nanoscale factor”, which, allied to
the high electronic conductivity in the solid phase, causes rapid charging of the faradaic capacitance-related
process. In our interpretation, the faradaic capacitance related process is linked to the insertion of Li
+
into the
solid-state phase of nanosized particles and can be interpreted as an ion immobilization or trapping process,
as discussed earlier in part 1.
I. Introduction
Nanocrystalline metal oxide electrodes have been incorporated
in electrochromic windows
1
and in ion-insertion batteries
2
with
significant technological and commercial potentiality. During
their operation, electrochromic windows and ion-insertion
batteries undergo a common event originating from the insertion
of Li
+
ions into the solid-state structure of the host materials,
for example, metal oxide electrodes. Despite the geometrical
porous effect, this event can be evaluated by frequency-
dependent techniques.
Nanoscale range materials have been widely studied for
application in energy storage devices due to their distinctive
properties, which originate from the presence of large numbers
of interfaces, a characteristic that can be exploited to design
more efficient devices, including those used for conversion and
energy storage. These features allow for several technological
applications, mainly in semiconductors and ceramics, depending
on the features of the interfaces. Despite these important
technological applications, the complex geometry of the elec-
trodes involved in such devices renders any modeling of the
transport of Li
+
ions difficult in terms of nanostructured insertion
electrodes. This complex situation has only recently begun to
be exploited from every standpoint to offer a predictable way
to design a wide range of new Li
+
ion insertion electrodes,
which might lead to improvements, particularly in the rate
capabilities of the electrodes used in communication and remote
sensing device batteries.
3
Still in regard to the use of nanoscale materials in the design
of electrodes for Li
+
insertion, it is important to mention
specifically the effects of the nanoporous geometry of the
electrodes, to which the classic theory of porous electrodes can
be applied, as stated in our previous article, Part 1. In an
approach based on a situation of porous geometry, the nano-
structured material and nanoporous geometry of lithium ion
electrodes can dramatically improve the rate capabilities of thin-
film dense materials because the distance that Li
+
diffuses in
nanostructured electrodes is restricted to the radius of the host
material’s nanocrystals or to the fibers in nanofiber-based
electrodes.
4-6
The prevailing idea regarding the kinetic reaction of elec-
troinsertion, from the standpoint of Li
+
insertion into the solid
state, is that the transport of mobile guests inside the host lattice
is the predominant step, with the guestssusually Li
+
ionss
moving by ordinary diffusion under semi-infinite conditions.
Thus, diffusion is considered the current- and power-limiting
step in Li ion insertion electrodes.
In the present paper, we analyze two distinct SnO
2
layers
having different nanocrystalline structures and electronic con-
ductivities with the specific purpose of evaluating the influence
of these features on the Li
+
charge kinetics, as was stated in
part 1 of this article. The charge modes were analyzed on the
basis of impedance and complex capacitance responses. Our
interpretation of the results indicates that the average size of
nanocrystalline particles improves the overall kinetics, because
Li
+
diffusion occurs rapidly through the bulk of SnO
2
-Sb
nanocrystal-based electrodes whose particle sizes are smaller
than those of the pure SnO
2
larger size nanoparticle-based
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: paulo@
iris.ufscar.br.
8878 J. Phys. Chem. B 2003, 107, 8878-8883
10.1021/jp034512m CCC: $25.00 © 2003 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 08/06/2003