Charge Transfer Complexes as Pan-Scaled Photoinitiating Systems:
From 50 μm 3D Printed Polymers at 405 nm to Extremely Deep
Photopolymerization (31 cm)
Patxi Garra, Bernadette Graff, Fabrice Morlet-Savary, Ce ́ line Dietlin, Jean-Michel Becht,
Jean-Pierre Fouassier, and Jacques Laleve ́ e*
Institut de Science des Mate ́ riaux de Mulhouse IS2M, UMR CNRS 7361, UHA, 15, rue Jean Starcky, Cedex 68057 Mulhouse, France
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Charge transfer complexes (CTC) between N-
aromatic amines (donors) and iodonium salts (acceptors) are used
here as photoinitiating systems (PIS) for the polymerization of clear
methacrylate formulations under a 405 nm LED irradiation.
Outstandingly, a complete spatial and temporal resolution is kept
for 50 μm resolved 3D printed photopolymers at 405 nm (50 μm
being the size of the printing laser used here). Photocuring of a high
thickness (31 cm) is also possible. The photopolymerization
propagation is rationalized and interpreted from both experimental
(using thermal imaging experiments) and predicted data. An
experimental/molecular modeling study also attempts to rationalize
the CTC structure/reactivity/efficiency relationships. These systems
are commercially available, stable, and metal-free and have a low
toxicity.
1. INTRODUCTION
Light-induced reactions are very interesting as they require
small energy amounts for reactions at mild temperatures
without significant emissions of VOC. Most of the time, they
result in excellent spatial and temporal controls. Nevertheless, a
huge limitation of them is the inner filter effect: light is mainly
absorbed by layers close to the light source, and a deep light
penetration is not possible (as due to the Beer-Lambert law
1
).
As a result, most applications of photochemistry are occurring
close to the surface receiving the actinic light, for example in
solar cells
2
or in continuous-flow photochemistry.
3
This is
particularly true for free radical photopolymerization:
4-12
most
of the current applications are often limited to thicknesses <100
μm in coatings, inks, paints, or composites even if polymers
concern much wider sizes of samples (45% of the manufactured
plastic materials are produced through free radical polymer-
ization processes
13
). There is therefore a need to (i) better
understand the inner filter effect on in depth photopolymeriza-
tion kinetics and (ii) to actually develop photoinitiating systems
(PIS) capable of producing pan-scaled and well-resolved (e.g.,
for 3D printing) polymer materials, i.e., from the micrometric
to the centimeter scale.
In the literature, many authors are tackling the issues of light
penetration, and this was summed up in a recent review.
14
Many years ago, mono- and bisacylphosphine oxides appeared
as the only family of photoinitiators being able to polymerize
clear, pigmented, filled, or glass reinforced fiber acrylate
coatings.
15-20
Thanks to the particular bleaching properties
of these compounds, the photocuring of 2.9 cm thick filled
materials and ∼10-15 cm thick clear varnishes has been
claimed. Nevertheless, long irradiation times and UV irradiation
sources were necessary for the curing of very thick samples
thanks to the photobleaching observed with acylphosphine
oxides (i.e., 25 min to cure a 8.5 cm of clear acrylate
formulation
21
). Developing systems active under near-infrared
irradiation sources
22-26
is a recent answer (to light penetration
issues in photopolymerization) particularly relevant when fillers
are causing some light diffusion enhancing inner filter effect,
e.g., in composites.
27-30
Very recently, another advanced report
stated the use of upconversion particles to produce the free
radical photopolymerization of acrylate samples up to 13.7
cm.
31
These upconversion particles (0.3 wt % particles in the
resin) re-emitted blue light (allowing photoinitiation by a
titanocene photoinitiator) upon a 980 nm high-intensity (9.4
W/cm
2
) laser beam. The evaluation of the spatial control of the
method was not presented.
Other recent different strategies involve the presence of
latent species created under a primary irradiation that will
diffuse through the entire polymerizable media, e.g., in
controlled photopolymerization under air,
32-36
UV-induced
photopolymerization triggered by photocaged amines,
37-39
a
process based on a diffusion by a leuco form of the dye,
40
or in
Received: October 11, 2017
Revised: November 22, 2017
Article
Cite This: Macromolecules XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acs.macromol.7b02185
Macromolecules XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX