Pergamon
PII: S0304-4181 (97)00011-0
Journal ~?fMedieval Histo O. Vol. 23, No. 4. pp. 317 334, 1997
© 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights re~erve~
Printed in The Netherlands
0304-4181/q7 $17.t)0 + 0.0()
A leper in purple: the coronation of Baldwin IV of Jerusalem ~
Stephen Lay
Department of History, Australian National University Canberra. ACT 0200. Australia
Abstract
Baldwin IV, the leper king of Jerusalem, was one of history's more startling monarchs. His
coronation in 1174 has been interpreted as anomalous or, alternatively, as evidence of unique
cultural and political trends within the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem. Inherent in all these
evaluations, however, is the unquestioned acceptance that Baldwin was known to be leprous at the
time of his coronation. This is an assumption that is supported by neither medical understandings
of the disease, nor by a consideration of the evidence that survives from the period. Though
clearly suffering from advanced leprosy at the time of his death, there is nothing to suggest that
Baldwin's disease could have been diagnosed prior to his taking the throne and so there is no need
to consider his coronation as anything other than a conventional one. © 1997 Elsevier Science
Ltd. All rights reserved
'It lies like a leper in purple. It sits like a dead thing smeared with gold. It is all
wrong, all wrong.' Oscar Wilde.
Oscar Wilde's analogy for a dysfunctional society was the paradoxical figure of a
leper enthroned. Interestingly, such a monarch is known to history: Baldwin IV, who
ruled the Latin Kingdom of Jerusalem from his coronation on 15 July 1174 until the
debilitating effects of advanced leprosy forced his abdication in 1185. A fearful
twelfth-century Europe imposed severe policies of exclusion on lepers, and if the
symptoms of Baldwin's disease were identifiable in 1174 his coronation would
constitute a glaring anomaly. Encouraged, perhaps, by the startling image of a leper
king, historians have assumed that this was the case. Like Wilde, they have linked the
elevation of a leper to abnormal social circumstances and explanations of Baldwin's
coronation are primarily based on a unique cultural and political climate in the
crusaders' states of Palestine. Yet there exists a simpler possibility: that at the time of
coronation the prince's symptoms were not yet apparent, or at least not yet unmistakably
those of leprosy. While the disease became increasingly obvious as Baldwin's reign
progressed, it is unlikely that a conclusive diagnosis of his condition could have been
STEPHEN LAY has recently completed a Master of Letters in History at the Australian National University.
~I am indebted to both W. G. Craven and J. H. Pryor for valuable advice and criticism during the preparation of
this article.