© Wilma A. Dunaway and Maria Cecilia Macabuac, 2023 | DOI:10.1163/9789004522657_007
This is an open access chapter distributed under the terms of the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 License.
CHAPTER 5
The World Does Not Weep for Us
Semiproletarianized Households, Nonwaged Labor and Depeasantization
Abstract
We analyze the human and community impacts that have followed the transformation
of a food self-sufficient region into a food extractive enclave. We examine how seafood
exporters keep global consumer prices fictitiously cheap through two interconnected
processes. On the one hand, seafood commodity chains structure mechanisms
through which exporters derive hidden labor subsidies from peasant households. On
the other hand, exporters keep prices low and profits higher by externalizing costs
of production to fisher households through livelihood threats, depeasantization, low
remuneration, debt bondage, degraded ecosystems and threats to human survival.
As a result of hidden household subsidies and externalization of costs, the United
Nations Human Development Indexes for our target fishery are among the worst in
the world. Even though their communities are exporting vast amounts of farm pro-
duce and seafoods, these peasants are 1.3 times more likely to fall below the food
threshold than other rural households. Moreover, fishery restructuring has led to
the alteration and intensification of women’s work in ways that threaten household
survival and food security.
Our government blames us for the environmental problems, tells us we
are in the way of progress, and wants us to go into alternative livelihoods
that will leave us even poorer. Fishponds and commercial trawlers are
killing our way of life. The world has not mourned the deaths of so many
of our small creatures and plants that were used to feed fishponds or
destroyed in commercial nets. And the world will not weep if we small
fishers starve.
(Panguil Bay Fisherwoman)
∵
In the previous chapter, we examined the restructuring of Philippine fishing
communities into food extractive enclaves, and we pinpointed the networks
Wilma A. Dunaway and Maria Cecilia Macabuac - 9789004522657
Downloaded from Brill.com04/21/2023 02:15:46PM
via free access