Journal of Constructional Steel Research 67 (2011) 1174–1184
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Constructional Steel Research
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jcsr
Experimental determination of the rotational capacity of wall-to-base
connections in storage tanks
G. Cortés
∗
, A. Nussbaumer, C. Berger, E. Lattion
Steel Structures Laboratory (ICOM), Swiss Federal Institute of Technology, 1015-Lausanne, Switzerland
article info
Article history:
Received 22 September 2010
Accepted 10 February 2011
Keywords:
Unanchored tanks
Rotational capacity
Uplift
Earthquake resistance
Fatigue
Wall-to-base connection
abstract
Earthquakes around the world have affected many unanchored tanks used for the storage of petroleum-
derived liquids. When these unanchored tanks are subjected to strong motion, the moment generated at
the base, by the mass of liquid contained in the tank, will cause partial uplift of the base (i.e. rocking of the
tank), inducing cycles of rotation at the wall-to-base connection. Actual codes of standard practice used
in Europe and New Zealand limit the rotation that may be allowed at this connection to 0.2 rad. This limit
was based on a series of assumptions since no realistic tests had been conducted. This paper presents the
experimental research conducted to determine the real rotational capacity of these connections. The tests
were carried out considering the bending stresses and the membrane stresses that develop at the base
plate when uplift occurs. Specimens from an old existing tank (dismantled) were used. New specimens
were also fabricated and used to allow for a more comprehensive study. Results from this research are
presented in the form of plots of maximum rotation vs. number of cycles to failure, called RN curves. These
curves revealed that the current Eurocodelimit of 0.2 rad is overly conservative. Based on the limited data,
a limit of 0.4 rad would be more realistic.
© 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
For many years thin shell tanks made from steel plates welded
together have been widely used to store liquids such as water,
gasoline and other petroleum-derived liquids. This type of tank is
very advantageous and cost effective since thin steel sheets welded
together are used. This is possible due to the effectiveness of the
shell to carry the hoop stresses that arise from the hydrostatic
pressure of the liquids in the walls. Moreover, very often these
tanks are designed and constructed without any anchorage to the
ground, further increasing the economy of these tanks. Thus, many
of these steel tanks lay on ground (usually compacted soil) on their
own weight.
Earthquakes around the world have affected many of these
tanks [1], resulting in economic losses from the loss of contents
and cost of rehabilitating/replacing the structure, and environmen-
tal hazards due to gasoline/petroleum spillage. The most common
types of damage observed in tanks are: damage to the roof caused
by the sloshing liquid near the roof, damage of the piping connec-
tions, damage to the tank walls, usually in the form of buckling
caused by the high compressive stresses in the walls of the tank,
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: gustavo.cortes@epfl.ch (G. Cortés), alain.nussbaumer@epfl.ch
(A. Nussbaumer), christoph.berger@proteng.co.jp (C. Berger),
eric.lattion@acs-partner.ch (E. Lattion).
and damage of the wall-to-base connection, caused by the uplift-
ing of the tank [2]. Fire and total collapse have also been observed
in some cases.
Many researchers have studied the behavior of these tanks
under seismic loads [3,4]. From these early studies it was found
that when the tank is subjected to lateral excitations, the lower
portion of the liquid stored was acting along with the tank while
the upper portion was displacing in a long-period sloshing mode.
The part that moves along with the tank is termed the impulsive
part, since it deforms rigidly with the tank. It is this part that
contributes the most to the base shear and overturning moment
in the tank. The sloshing portion of the liquid, also called the
convective liquid, is responsible for most damage observed in the
roof. Enough clearance should be provided to avoid any damage in
the roof.
The behavior of an unanchored tank is similar to that of an
anchored tank under small magnitudes of ground displacement.
However, when the shaking of the ground is strong enough, the
moment generated at the base by the impulsive mass will cause
partial uplift of the base (i.e. rocking of the tank). The phenomenon
of rocking causes an increase in the period of the tank, and thus,
an increase in the deformations experienced by the tank. Uplift of
the tank is mainly affected by the height-to-radius ratio (H/R) of
the tank, the thickness of the base plate, the configuration of the
connection, and the stiffness of the underlying soil. While all these
parameters have some influence over the rocking behavior of the
tank, the H/R ratio has the greatest influence. A tall tank would
0143-974X/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.jcsr.2011.02.010