Int. J. Society Systems Science, Vol. 1, No. 4, 2009 307
Copyright © 2009 Inderscience Enterprises Ltd.
Non-profit and for profit convergence: are non-profits
increasingly adopting private sector practices?
Andres Ramirez*
Bryant University,
1150 Douglas Pike, Smithfield RI 02917, USA
E-mail: aramirez@bryant.edu
*Corresponding author
Kelly Janiga
Ross School of Business,
University of Michigan,
724 E. University, Wyly Hall Ann Arbor, MI 48103, USA
E-mail: janigak@umich.edu
Abstract: The role of the non-profit has traditionally been thought to create
social value, while for-profit organisations have been held responsible for
economic value creation. However, we now see this dichotomy blurring and
organisations marrying social interest and market mechanisms to create both
social and economic value (Alter, 2006).
In this paper, we examine whether some of the strategic decisions and
actions made by non-profits are converging with those being made by
for-profits, particularly with regard to four important strategy issues: money,
management, mission maximisation and metrics, which we frame as the four
Ms. We hypothesise that if the convergence is occurring, non-profits would,
overtime, be making decisions and implementing subsequent actions
increasingly similar to those being made in the for-profit sector. Through the
use of a literature review and empirical evidence we show that non-profit
decisions and actions are, in fact, becoming increasingly similar to those of
for-profit organisations.
Keywords: convergence of sectors; non-profit sector; social enterprise;
financial leverage; financial management; social innovation; endowments.
Reference to this paper should be made as follows: Ramirez, A. and Janiga, K.
(2009) ‘Non-profit and for profit convergence: are non-profits increasingly
adopting private sector practices?’, Int. J. Society Systems Science, Vol. 1,
No. 4, pp.307–324.
Biographical notes: Andres Ramirez is Assistant Professor of Finance at
Bryant University, where he teaches International Finance and Business in
Latin America classes. He obtained his PhD in International Finance at the
University of South Carolina. His research deals with the impact of sociological
factors on corporate financial decisions as well as non-profit financial
management and planning. A native of Chile, he pursued a career as a treasurer,
controller and ERP manager before joining the academe. As a member of a
Chilean multinational firm, he worked with subsidiaries in Argentina,
Venezuela, Brazil and Mexico.