Electrical Power and Energy Systems 125 (2021) 106549
Available online 2 October 2020
0142-0615/© 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
The failure arc paths of the novel device combining an arrester and an
insulator under different pollution levels
Xinhan Qiao
a, b
, Zhijin Zhang
a, *
, Raji Sundararajan
b
, Xingliang Jiang
a
, Jianping Hu
c
,
Zhen Fang
c
a
Chongqing University, No. 174, Shazheng Street, Shapingba District, Chongqing 400044, China
b
Purdue University, 401 N. Grant St., West Lafayette, IN 47907, USA
c
State Key Laboratory of Disaster Prevention and Reduction for Power Grid Transmission and Distribution Equipment State Grid, Disaster Prevention and Reduction
Center, State Grid Hunan Electric Power Company Ltd., Changsha 401205, China
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Failure arc path
Impulse voltage waveform
Arresters
Lightning protection
Pollution levels
ABSTRACT
Lightning strokes on transmission lines could trigger insulation failure if no protective measures are taken.
Typically, a lightning arrester is used for this purpose. In order to combine the insulator and the lightning arrester
as a single entity, a novel lightning protection composite insulator, combining an arrester and an insulator was
developed for 10 kV distribution lines. Studied in this paper are the various arc paths of the novel insulator. The
arc path tests under both AC and impulse voltage were conducted. The fndings indicate that low, medium, high,
very high, and extremely heavy pollutions caused different types of arcings under AC voltage. In addition, arc
paths were affected by both the pollution level and the magnitude of impulse voltage. Based on the arc paths
recorded by a high-speed camera, the fashover modes can be divided into three categories (fashover of the air
gap, fashover of silicone rubber sheds in insulation section, and fashover of the whole insulator). More spe-
cifcally, we defned and analyzed 14 types of arc paths in detail, and the critical pollution level (0.1 mg/cm
2
) of
normal operation were obtained. Further, the statistical probability of each arc under impulse voltage was
calculated. Due to the complexity of the arc paths under the switching impulse voltage, a 90% probability
distribution fgure of arc paths with different U
s
(switching impulse voltage) and ESDD (equivalent salt deposit
density) was presented according to the test results. At last, we discuss the impulse voltage waveform corre-
sponding to the typical arc path and describe the research prospect. The research results in this paper present the
failure modes of the novel lightning protection insulator, and the results can be used for designing insulators for
various pollution levels.
1. Introduction
Lightning strokes on transmission lines could trigger insulation
failure if protective measures are not taken [1–3], causing power failure,
resulting in economic losses [4,5]. The lightning strokes have gradually
become the most leading cause of power grid trip-out on high voltage
lines. Taking the operation data of 500 kV transmission lines of South
China Power Grid in a specifc year as an example, 62 grid trip-outs
occurred, 54 of which were caused by lightning strikes, accounting for
87.1% [6]. For 10 kV distribution networks, taking the operation data in
Qingcheng District Guangzhou Province as an example, 310 grid trip-
outs occurred in 2016, 164 of which were caused by lightning strikes,
accounting for 52.9% [7].
To prevent lightning fashover accidents, overhead grounding lines
and transmission-line arresters are used in service [8–12]. Some scholars
focus on the development of new arresters and their applications
[13,14]. Two types of transmission-line arresters are mainly adopted
[15]: air-gapped and gapless arresters. Gapless arresters are generally
installed in the substation or on the frst foundation tower near the
substation. It is used to protect the electrical equipment of substation
from the damage of lightning. During the operation of the gapless
arrester, the voltage is applied to the arrester, which accelerates the
aging of the arrester. Besides, the performance of the arrester should be
tested before the thunderstorm season every year, and it involves lots of
repetition work and costs much time and labor. Compared with gapless
arrester, air-gapped arresters is easier to maintain. However, when
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: zhangzhijing@cqu.edu.cn (Z. Zhang).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
International Journal of Electrical Power and Energy Systems
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ijepes
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijepes.2020.106549
Received 11 June 2020; Received in revised form 12 August 2020; Accepted 20 September 2020