Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Electric Power Systems Research
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/epsr
Robust pseudo-measurement modeling for three-phase distribution systems
state estimation
Zhiyuan Cao
a,
*, Yubo Wang
b
, Chi-Cheng Chu
a
, Rajit Gadh
a
a
Smart Grid Energy Research Center, University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA 90095, United States
b
Siemens Corporate Technology, Princeton, NJ 08540, United States
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Pseudo-measurement modeling
Three-phase distribution system state
estimation
Gradient boosting tree method
ABSTRACT
Trending integration of distributed energy resources calls for state estimation at the distribution level for pro-
viding reliable power systems information. In contrast to transmission systems, distribution systems are sparsely
monitored, and consequently difficult to estimate states. To address measurement scarcity problem in dis-
tribution systems, this paper proposes a distribution system state estimation framework that relies on robust
pseudo-measurement modeling. User-level metering data is used to train gradient boosting tree models for
generating pseudo-measurements. A ladder iterative state estimator is then applied on the pseudo-measurements
to solve for system states. Simulation studies are performed on the IEEE 13-bus and 123-bus test feeders.
Numerical results demonstrate that the proposed state estimation scheme outperform two benchmark ap-
proaches in terms of accuracy (error), consistency (error variance) and robustness (high accuracy subject to load
changes).
1. Introduction
State estimation has been a backbone application for transmission
systems. It utilizes real and reactive power injection, voltage and cur-
rent measurements and phase angles collected from Supervisory
Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) system and Phasor Measurement
Units (PMUs), working as an estimator between raw measurements and
system states [1].
In recent years, increasing penetration of distributed energy re-
sources (DERs) has brought attention to distribution management sys-
tems (DMS). The uncertainties introduced by DERs requires to be
regulated by DMS. Such management relies on highly reliable mea-
surements provided by state estimations.
While state estimation is well-developed in transmission systems, a
simple migration does not solve the problem at the distribution level for
two main reasons. First, due to the properties of distribution systems
such as high R/X ratio, short-line and unbalanced phases, the tradi-
tional weighted least square (WLS) based methods tend to have poor
convergence when applied at the distribution level [2]. Research on
solving the three-phase state estimation problem can be traced back to
1990s [3], and it is also heatedly studied in recent years. In [4], a three-
phase state estimation based on forward/backward sweep is given. The
method exploits the radial nature of the distribution networks. The
authors in [5] used branch currents as state variables to allow
decoupling of the three-phase model. The method treats each phase as a
separate state estimation problem to improve convergence. It is further
improved in [6] with the integration of distributed generations (DG). In
[7], the authors presented a method based on extended optimal power
flow with consideration of different network configurations. More re-
cently, heuristic algorithms are gaining popularity. In [8], a hybrid
particle swarm optimization is implemented to solve the three-phase
state estimation problem. A method based on ordinal optimization is
applied in [9]. Meanwhile, three-phase state estimation based on PMUs
is also gaining much attention because PMUs provide direct measure-
ments of the state (voltage readings and angles). In [10], a method
based on a few micro-PMUs using compressive sensing is implemented.
The authors in [11] present a PMU based state estimation method with
special consideration of harmonic monitoring. In [12], a distributed
state estimation scheme is proposed, in which area with remote term-
inal units (RTU) measurements is solved with nonlinear equations and
area with PMU measurements is solved with linear equations. Because
PMUs are usually expensive, PMU placement is also studied in dis-
tribution networks. In [13], a placement method is introduced with a
focus on DG output power.
Second, a lack of synchronized measurements in the distribution
grid often exists. In most of the existing systems, SCADA readings are
available only at the substation level [14]. Pseudo-measurements
modeled from historical data are often applied to fill the gap of
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.epsr.2019.106138
Received 2 May 2019; Received in revised form 27 November 2019; Accepted 29 November 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: oreki47@ucla.edu (Z. Cao).
Electric Power Systems Research 180 (2020) 106138
Available online 13 December 2019
0378-7796/ © 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T