Bamboo Usage in Orthopedic: An Attempt to Reconcile Materials
Properties with the Biomechanics of Human Walking
Publication History:
Received: June 12, 2020
Accepted: July 15, 2020
Published: July 17, 2020
Keywords:
Exoskeleton, Formability,
Fracture toughness, Gait, Moso
bamboo
Original Article Open Access
Background
Current exoskeletons
Tis work presents a more comprehensive assessment of the use
of natural materials in orthopedic application and it is a follow up
on a previous paper which dealt with the use of low-cost material for
exoskeletal application. Gait is fundamental to the quality of life [1].
Gait is essential to basic activities of daily living (ADLs) to one’s ability
to carry out functional tasks for independent living. For person’s
living with gait and balance disorders, gait abnormality can limit
quality of function and create barriers on activity performance and
participation [2]. Tis is particularly signifcant for the lower extremity
(LE) amputee, where the major limitation is ofen the difculty with
walking [2,3]. In addition, the cost of prosthetic devices essential to
restore function in people with gait dysfunction is not afordable to
many. Depending on the type of prosthetic leg, the cost of prosthesis
can typically range from $5,000 for a basic prosthetic leg to above
$70,000 for an advanced computerized prosthetic leg and exoskeletons,
and the prosthesis may only last anywhere from three to fve years
before requiring replacement related to conditions of wear and tear
[3]. While continual adjustments and numerous replacements will
be needed during the lifetime of the amputee; for the patient without
health insurance, the long-term costs associated with prosthetic care
may not be afordable. While prostheses are artifcial devices used to
replace missing body parts, exoskeletons work in parallel with the
body to assist the user in their movements. Although both devices
are primarily used for rehabilitation purposes, Exoskeletons can also
be used as safety equipment. Te exoskeletons that are used for safety
equipment, assist workers in performing hazardous jobs with minimal
*
Corresponding Author: Aruoture Egoh, Department of Mechanical Engineering,
FAMU-FSU College of Engineering, Tallahassee, FL 32310, USA; Tel: +1 850 345
7857; E-mail: aruoture1.egoh@famu.edu
Citation: Carnrike T, Egoh A, Reed KS, Kalu PN (2020) Bamboo Usage in Orthopedic:
An Attempt to Reconcile Materials Properties with the Biomechanics of Human
Walking. Int J Phys Ther Rehab 6: 164. doi: https://doi.org/10.15344/2455-
7498/2020/164
Copyright: © 2020 Carnrike et al. This is an open-access article distributed
under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the
original author and source are credited.
injuries [4]. When used for rehabilitation purposes, the individuals in
question are usually sufering from debilitating neurological or limb
pathologies lacking sufcient strength, power, torque, and endurance
[5]. Exoskeletons can be used to target the full body, upper extremities,
and lower extremities [6]. Figures 1-4 presents the diferent types of
exoskeletons used for lower extremities, and they are classifed as
powered, passive, pseudo-passive, and hybrid [5,7-10].
Obviously, exoskeletons enable people with serious mobility issues
to leave their wheelchairs behind. Te main issue is that the cost of
a wheelchair is cheaper than an exoskeleton which is why health
insurers don’t see its beneft. When the price of the exoskeletons
become comparable to that of a wheelchair then insurance companies
will consider these devices for personal use. Physical therapy ofces
and large companies are the current exoskeleton customers. Te high
cost of exoskeletons can be attributed partly to the cost of the material
it is made out of. Exoskeletons currently available are typically made
of Duralumin (Al-2024 T6). Other materials investigated were either
too heavy (steel) or too expensive (carbon fber). In order to replace
International Journal of
Physical Terapy & Rehabilitation
Talya Carnrike
1
, Aruoture Egoh
1*
, Kischa S. Reed
2
and Peter N. Kalu
1
1
Department of Mechanical Engineering, FAMU-FSU College of Engineering, Tallahassee, FL 32310, USA
2
Division of Physical Terapy, Florida A&M University, Tallahassee, FL 32307, USA
Int J Phys Ter Rehab IJPTR, an open access journal
ISSN: 2455-7498 Volume 6. 2020. 164
Carnrike et al., Int J Phys Ther Rehab 2020, 6: 164
https://doi.org/10.15344/2455-7498/2020/164
Abstract
Background: Tis work is part of an ongoing study on the use of natural materials to provide low cost
exoskeleton and orthopedic devices in general. An earlier work showed that fr, pine, oak and bamboo
satisfed the requirements of the mid-stance of the Gait cycle which is about 10% of a person’s total weight.
In reality, there are eight determinants of the gait cycle and they involve pelvic rotation and tilt, in addition
to foot mechanics, knee mechanics and lateral displacement of pelvis. Furthermore, during walking, the
peak vertical ground reaction force can rise up to 1.2 times the body weight. Terefore, any replacement
exoskeleton material is expected to withstand this amount of compressive force and the rotational torques
as well as possess excellent fracture toughness.
Methods: Te eight determinants of the gait cycle of normal walking were analyzed with along their
consideration that during walking, the peak vertical ground reaction force can rise up to 1.2 times the body
weight. Te materials selection process utilized the Ashby’s procedure and consists of four steps, namely:
translation, screening, ranking and documentation. Additional assessment of the fracture toughness and
formability of the materials were carried out.
Results: While all the natural materials satisfed the basic selection, process based on cost and weight, only
oak and Moso bamboo fulflled the additional requirement of strength and formability. Oak was however
eliminated due to its characteristic low fracture toughness which means that it is unable to provide the
weight bearing support in the stance phase.
Conclusion: All the natural materials studied satisfed the cost and weight requirements for low-cost
orthopedic devices. However, only Moso bamboo with its characteristic high fracture toughness and
formability can comfortably replace duralumin in exoskeleton.