RESEARCH AND ANALYSIS
Reevaluation of Energy Use in
Wheat Production in the
United States
Gerhard Piringer and Laura J. Steinberg
Summary
Energy budgets for agricultural production can be used as
building blocks for life-cycle assessments that include agri-
cultural products, and can also serve as a first step toward
identifying crop production processes that benefit most from
increased efficiency. A general trend toward increased energy
efficiency in U.S. agriculture has been reported. For wheat
cultivation, in particular, this study updates cradle-to-gate pro-
cess analyses produced in the seventies and eighties. Input
quantities were obtained from official U.S. statistics and other
sources and multiplied by calculated or recently published en-
ergy coefficients. The total energy input into the production
of a kilogram of average U.S. wheat grain is estimated to range
from 3.1 to 4.9 MJ/kg, with a best estimate at 3.9 MJ/kg. The
dominant contribution is energy embodied in nitrogen fertil-
izer at 47% of the total energy input, followed by diesel fuel
(25%), and smaller contributions such as energy embodied in
seed grain, gasoline, electricity, and phosphorus fertilizer. This
distribution is reflected in the energy carrier mix, with natu-
ral gas dominating (57%), followed by diesel fuel (30%). High
variability in energy coefficients masks potential gains in total
energy efficiency as compared to earlier, similar U.S. studies.
Estimates from an input-output model for several input pro-
cesses agree well with process analysis results, but the model’s
application can be limited by aggregation issues: Total energy
inputs for generic food grain production were lower than
wheat fertilizer inputs alone, possibly due to aggregation of
diverse products into the food grain sector.
Keywords
agriculture
carrier mix
energy balance
grain
input-output model
process analysis
e-supplement available on the JIE
Web site
Address correspondence to:
Laura J. Steinberg
Department of Civil and Environmental
Engineering
Tulane University
New Orleans, LA 70118
<lauras@tulane.edu>
© 2006 by the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology and Yale University
Volume 10, Number 1–2
http://mitpress.mit.edu/jie Journal of Industrial Ecology 149