Research Article
Surfactant Effects on Aeration Performance
of Stirred Tank Reactors
The effect of surfactants on aeration performance in stirred tank reactors (STR)
at high rates of foaming is studied. The volumetric oxygen transfer coefficient
(k
L
a) and foaming activity estimated as foaming height (H
f
) were determined.
Biotechnology of lipopeptide biosurfactants from aerobic organisms, e.g., Bacillus
subtilis were addressed. Using model solutions of known foam-generating
properties, high-molecular weight surfactin and low-molecular weight sodium
dodecyl sulphate (SDS), as well as impellers of different types, with flat and fluid-
foil blades, clues on the concentration dependence of STR oxygen transfer and
foaming as well as options for foam reduction in the presence of biosurfactant
were sought. In response to a two-fold decrease of surface tension by surfactin,
k
L
a values decreased up to 30 % but remained within the range expected for the
mixing system in water; the experiments with SDS showing stronger dependence
on surfactant concentration and surface tension. Mixing of surfactant media by a
standard six-blade disc turbine (RT) imposed rate limitations on gassing. A low-
shear impeller Narcissus (NS) could be used to avoid bulk foam outflow, while
preserving k
L
a values that remained unchanged. The ‘power per unit volume’ cor-
relation of k
L
a in stirred tanks is tested in the presence of surfactin.
Keywords: Agitation, Gas-liquid systems, Mass transfer, Surfactant, Foaming
Received: October 24, 2007; revised: July 22, 2008; accepted: August 12, 2008
DOI: 10.1002/ceat.200700401
1 Introduction
Stirred tank reactors are key processing vessels in biotechnol-
ogy and the rate of oxygen delivery determines, in many cases,
the efficiency of aerobic treatment. Depending on the media
involved, mass transfer is influenced by liquid properties, such
as surface tension, density, viscosity, etc. Most frequently, the
systems are foaming because of the presence of cell proteins
and/or surface active products of a specific nature, e.g., biolog-
ical surfactants. In cases of surfactant products, important
variables are product concentrations and foaming. To improve
mass transfer efficiency, data on the gas-liquid mass transfer
coefficient and the range of foaming activity is needed.
An important case study is seen in biosurfactant production,
in particular those related to bio-production of lipopeptides
[1]; some of them, such as iturin, surfactin, and fengycin are
highly surface active. Due to their biological and physical
chemical properties, they are subject to significant commercial
interest [2–6]. Among them, surfactin exhibits extremely high
foaming capacity [7]. Combined with biodegradability, its
properties render the substance as a highly demanded product
[2–7]. In order to increase the production prospects, the fer-
mentation rate has to be increased. Referring to the fact that
most biosurfactant-producing organisms are aerobic, develop-
ments have to focus on aeration. Nevertheless, specific oxygen
transfer rates and their relationships with surfactant concen-
tration and foaming conditions at agitation are largely un-
known [8]. So far, only one study of a similar problem has
come to the authors’ attention. Sheppard and Cooper [9] have
studied the effect of the cell-free production medium upon
oxygen transfer in a cyclone tower. Being fluid flow sensitive,
the process was carried out at constant gassing rate, at no agi-
tation or excessive foaming. No pure biosurfactant or foaming
aspects were considered. The paper delivered important data
on the effect of nutrient constituents, pH, and liquid volume
on aeration in the presence of surfactant. However, as far as
seen also from their analysis, the process is accompanied by
some difficulties: On the one hand, this is the extent of foam-
ing. On the other hand, the lipopeptide accumulates at the
gas-liquid interface and changes the system transport proper-
ties. Both aspects invoke further analysis of the lipopeptide ef-
© 2008 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim http://www.cet-journal.com
Martin Martinov
1
Frederique Gancel
2
Philippe Jacques
2
Iordan Nikov
2
Serafim Vlaev
1
1
Institute of Chemical
Engineering, Bulgarian
Academy of Sciences, Sofia,
Bulgaria.
2
Polytech’ Lille, Département
IAAL ProBioGEM, Université
des Sciences et Technologies
de Lille, Cité Scientifique,
Villeneuve d’Ascq, France.
–
Correspondence: Prof. S. D. Vlaev (mixreac@bas.bg), Institute of
Chemical Engineering, Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, Acad.G. Bonchev
Str. Bl. 103, 1113 Sofia, Bulgaria.
1494 Chem. Eng. Technol. 2008, 31, No. 10, 1494–1500