Disorder-Induced Capillary Bursts Control Intermittency in Slow Imbibition
Xavier Clotet,
1,2
Jordi Ortín,
1
and Stéphane Santucci
2
1
Departament ECM, Facultat de Física, Universitat de Barcelona, Martí i Franquès 1, 08028 Barcelona, Catalonia, Spain
2
Laboratoire de Physique, CNRS UMR 5672, École Normale Supérieure de Lyon, 46 Allée d’Italie, 69364 Lyon Cedex 07, France
(Received 11 October 2013; published 13 August 2014)
A multiscale analysis of the spatially averaged velocity of an imbibition front V
l
ðtÞ measured at scale l
reveals that the slow front dynamics is intermittent: the distributions of ΔV
l
ðτÞ¼ V
l
ðt þ τÞ - V
l
ðtÞ evolve
continuously through time scales τ, from heavy-tailed to Gaussian—reached at a time lag τ
c
set by the
extent of the medium heterogeneities. Intermittency results from capillary bursts triggered from the smallest
scale of the disorder up to the scale l
c
at which viscous dissipation becomes dominant. The effective
number of degrees of freedom of the front l = l
c
controls its intensity.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.113.074501 PACS numbers: 47.56.+r, 05.40.-a, 47.53.+n
The heterogeneous structure of porous and fractured
media can lead to complex spatiotemporal fluid invasion
dynamics, with kinetic roughening [1–4], avalanches [5–8],
and non-Gaussian velocity fluctuations [5–7,9] of the
invading fronts. It, thus, brings forward challenging fun-
damental questions in the context of out-of-equilibrium
dynamical systems [10], relevant to many processes of
interest [11].
Among the striking spatiotemporal features of porous
media flows, persistent intermittent properties of
Lagrangian velocities have been observed very recently in
numerical simulations [12]. Intermittency is a key concept
in hydrodynamic turbulence, associated with the occur-
rence of bursts of intense motion within more quiescent fluid
flow [13]. It leads to strong deviations from Gaussian
statistics, that become larger when considering fluctuations
at smaller scales [14,15]. In the context of interfacial
dynamics, small-scale intermittency was observed in grav-
ity-capillary wave turbulence [16], a system which strongly
differs from high Reynolds hydrodynamic turbulence [17].
Thus, understanding the physical mechanism of intermit-
tency remains a challenge [16–20]. Recently, it was sug-
gested that it could be related to the properties of the
fluctuations of the energy flux shared by different systems
displaying an energy cascade [16,17].
In this Letter, we perform a multiscale analysis (in space
and time) of the spatially averaged velocity of a fluid front
slowly invading a disordered medium. While in Ref. [6] we
studied the statistical properties of this velocity, the novel
study presented here reveals that this velocity displays
complex temporal correlations and exhibits all the distin-
guishing features of an intermittent dynamics. More
importantly, expanding the experimental parameter space
by using fluids of different viscosities and a wider range of
imposed flow rates, we disclose which variables control
intermittency in this system. Our work provides the first
experimental evidence and detailed characterization of
intermittency in fluid invasion of confined heterogeneous
media, and brings new insight into the origin of intermit-
tency in extended nonequilibrium systems.
Our experiments emulated the invasion of an open
fracture of variable aperture by a wetting, viscous fluid.
The experimental setup, shown in the top panel of Fig. 1,
has been described in detail elsewhere [4,7]. We recall,
briefly, its main features. It consists of two horizontal,
parallel glass plates (190 × 500 mm
2
), separated by a
narrow gap spacing. Nonoverlapping square patches
(0.4 × 0.4 mm
2
) randomly distributed in space and filling
35% of the bottom plate provide dichotomic fluctuations of
the gap thickness between 0.40 and 0.46 mm, modifying
the permeability κ of the cell [21]. In these conditions, the
lateral extent of the islands formed by adjacent patches
FIG. 1 (color online). Top: Sketch of the model disordered
medium. It is formed by two parallel, closely spaced glass plates
(G). Copper patches (Cu) of lateral size 0.4 × 0.4 mm
2
and
0.06 mm height, randomly deposited without overlapping,
cover 35% of the bottom fiber glass plate (FG). Middle:
Global velocity, V
l
ðtÞ, computed from an experiment with
v ¼ 0.053 mm=s and μ ¼ 50 cP ( l
c
≃ 11 mm), observed on a
scale l ¼ L=8 ¼ 17 mm. Bottom: Corresponding time-
derivative, A
l
ðtÞ.
PRL 113, 074501 (2014)
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS
week ending
15 AUGUST 2014
0031-9007=14=113(7)=074501(5) 074501-1 © 2014 American Physical Society