0018-9464 (c) 2016 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission. See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.
This article has been accepted for publication in a future issue of this journal, but has not been fully edited. Content may change prior to final publication. Citation information: DOI 10.1109/TMAG.2017.2714841, IEEE
Transactions on Magnetics
AS-12
0018-9464 © 2015 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information. (Inserted by IEEE.)
1
Dual Tuning of Doubly-Hybridized Spin-Electromagnetic Waves in
All-Thin-Film Multiferroic Multilayers
Aleksei A. Nikitin
1
, Vitaliy V. Vitko
1
, Andrey A. Nikitin
1,2
, Alexandr V. Kondrashov
1,2
, Alexey B. Ustinov
1,2
,
Alexander A. Semenov
1
, and Erkki Lähderanta
2
1
Department of Physical Electronics and Technology, St. Petersburg Electrotechnical University, St. Petersburg, 197376, Russia
2
Department of Mathematics and Physics, Lappeenranta University of Technology, Lappeenranta, 53850, Finland
Theoretical investigation of dual (electric and magnetic) tuning of dispersion characteristics has been studied for the doubly-
hybridized spin-electromagnetic waves (SEWs) propagating perpendicularly to the direction of static magnetization in tangentially
magnetized all-thin-film multiferroic multilayers. The multilayers consisted of two thin ferrite films separated by a thin ferroelectric
film. The SEW spectrum was formed due to double hybridization among one electromagnetic mode and two spin-wave modes. Such
hybridization took place if the initial dispersion characteristics of these modes were degenerated. The electric tuning was realized
owing to changing of the magneto-dipole interaction between the magnetic films caused by a variation of dielectric constant of the
ferroelectric film. It was shown that a decrease in permittivity of the ferroelectric film of micrometer thickness by a factor of two
induces change of the SEW wavenumber up to tens of radian per centimeter.
Index Terms—ferroelectrics, ferrites, multiferroics, spin-electromagnetic waves.
I. INTRODUCTION
NCREASED demands to frequency-agile materials used for
microwave applications has led to appearance of artificial
multiferroics [1]. Artificial multiferroics are usually fabricated
with a combination of ferrite and ferroelectric layers, so as to
obtain micro- and nanostructures [2], [3]. An interaction
between the ferromagnetic and ferroelectric phases is realized
through electrodynamic coupling of spin and electromagnetic
waves. This interaction leads to a formation of spin-
electromagnetic waves (SEWs) [4]. Dispersion characteristics
of hybrid spin-electromagnetic waves (SEWs) combine
features of electromagnetic waves in ferroelectric-based
materials and spin waves in ferrites. Therefore, the resulting
wave spectrum is dually controllable by the both electric and
magnetic fields. The electric tuning is realized through the
variation of dielectric permittivity of the ferroelectric layer by
changing the applied electric field. The magnetic tuning is
provided by a dependence of magnetic permeability of ferrites
on the bias magnetic field.
As it was shown earlier, degrees of hybridization strongly
depend on a overlapping of the dynamics fields of the
electromagnetic and spin waves. The overlapping depends on
the geometry of the layered structures and parameters of the
materials [4].
Until now the high research activity was mainly given to
two layered multiferroic structures consisted of one ferrite and
one ferroelectric layer [4]-[18]. An effective coupling at
microwave frequencies was achieved in multiferroic structures
fabricated with a relatively thick (200-500 µm) ferroelectric
layers [19]. Such thicknesses of the ferroelectric layer lead to
relatively high control voltages (up to 1000 V) needed for an
effective electric tuning of the SEW dispersion characteristics.
Recently, all-thin-film multiferroic structures based on slot
transmission line were suggested in order to decrease the
thickness of the ferroelectrics [20], [21]. In the latter work, a
decrease in the control voltage and increase in the tuning
efficiency were achieved with the reduction of the slot-line
gap width. However, in practice such a reduction is limited by
increase of losses in metal electrodes. In our opinion, further
advances in the dual-tunable multiferroic devices could be
achieved with development of the ferrite-ferroelectric-ferrite
structures [22], [23]. One of the main advantages of these
structures is existence of magneto-dipole interaction between
the ferrite films separated with a thin ferroelectric film. It
leads to a complication of the SEW spectrum, which is formed
due to interaction between two pure spin-wave modes and one
electromagnetic mode. Two possible situations are shown in
Fig. 1. The first hybridization takes place in the point I
between two spin-wave modes shown by dashed lines. The
second hybridization with electromagnetic mode could take
place in the same point or in the other points (e.g. points II and
III) depending on the parameters of the structure. The first
situation, in which all dispersion curves cross each other in
one point, is called as “double hybridization”.
Fig. 1. Qualitative picture of showing possible relative positions of two pure
spin-wave modes (dotted lines) and electromagnetic mode (solid line).
The purpose of this work is to theoretically investigate the
SEW spectra formed due to double hybridization. Such a
hybridization provides an effective tuning of the SEW
I