z Electro, Physical & Theoretical Chemistry
Comprehensive Understanding of Bi-functional Behavior of
PNP-Pincer Complexes Towards the Conversion of CO into
Methanol and CO
2
:ADFTApproach
Tamalika Ash, Tanay Debnath, and Abhijit K. Das*
[a]
The conversion mechanisms of CO into methanol through
hydrogenation and CO
2
through hydrolysis catalyzed by (PNP)
RuH
2
CO (1) pincer complex have been explored employing
density functional theory (DFT). For both the reactions, we
have identified two pathways. In pathway-I, at first the CO
takes part in the reaction by interacting with the Ru-center of
pincer complex and after that the H
2
/H
2
O molecule participates
in the reaction, whereas in pathway-II, the generation of
hydrogenated/hydrolyzed pincer from initial pincer via the
assistance of H
2
or H
2
O molecule occurs first, followed by the
reaction with CO. In case of hydrogenation, for both the
pathways, CO is first converted to HCHO through hydro-
genation which further undergoes hydrogenation to form
methanol. In pathway-I, the reaction of HCHO with H
2
in
presence of dehydrogenated pincer leads to produce meth-
anol, whereas for pathway-II the hydrogenated pincer formed
at the beginning of this pathway carries out the aforemen-
tioned conversion. Further in presence of methanol, CO is
catalytically converted to methyl formate. On the other hand,
in case of hydrolysis, the conversion of CO to CO
2
can be
achieved in two ways, where 2
nd
step, i.e. formic acid to CO
2
via
formate ion formation follows similar mechanism for both the
pathways. Overall, from our study it is revealed that the Ru-
pincer complex acts as a promising homogeneous catalyst for
converting CO to various organic chemical commodities.
1. Introduction
Carbon monoxide is a well-known green house gas. It is toxic
to hemoglobic animals when the concentration is above
∼ 35 ppm.
[1]
In presence of CO, hemoglobin gets converted into
carboxyhemoglobin through formation of metal-carbonyl
bond, which is ineffective for delivering oxygen into tissues.
[2]
Apart from the toxic character, the vast application of CO in the
chemical industry should also be noted in this regard. CO, in
the form of syn-gas and water-gas, is highly utilized as the
feedstock of various organic chemical commodity production,
such as formaldehyde, methanol, methane, formic acid etc. in
the industrial sector.
CO, being π-acidic ligand, shows some unique bonding
pattern. In case of transition metal complexes, CO forms bond
using synergic π-back bonding. The formation of σ-bond takes
place because of the overlap of nonbonding (or weakly anti-
bonding) sp-hybridized electron pair on carbon with a blend of
d-, s-, and p-orbitals on the metal, whereas π-bond arises due
to the overlap of filled d-orbitals on the metal with a pair of π-
antibonding orbitals projecting from the carbon center of the
CO. On the other hand, during the hydrogenation and
hydrolysis of CO, the simultaneous transfer of proton and
hydride/hydroxide occurs to the same carbon-center of CO.
Hence, whether the metal-carbonyl bond formation or the
nucleophilic/electrophilic attack to CO is considered, both of
them are observed to be a mono-centric chemical processes.
This unique behavior of CO differentiates it’s bonding pattern
from that of other unsaturated molecules.
Experimentally, the hydrogenation and hydrolysis of CO
without the assistance of any catalyst are difficult to achieve.
Thus, a variety of heterogeneous
[3–29]
and homogeneous
[30–34]
catalytic processes have been adopted till date to convert CO
containing gases (syn-gas and water-gas) into the aforemen-
tioned organic molecules. In 1921, Patart first reported the
synthesis of methanol from CO and H
2
.
[35]
In 1989, Inoue et al.
[4]
succeeded to perform the hydrogenation of CO
2
and CO under
10 bar in presence of supported Rh-catalysts, where they
obtained higher hydrocarbons and ethanol as products. Very
recently, Studt et al.
[15]
reported the hydrogenation of CO
mediated by Cu Ni bimetallic surface from both the exper-
imental as well as theoretical perspectives. Santiago-Rodriguez
et al.
[24]
investigated the catalytic performance of metal (Ga, Mg
and Ti)-doped Cu(111) surfaces in the hydrogenation of CO
2
and CO employing DFT methods. Applicability of homoge-
neous catalysis for the conversion of CO is also one of the
pivotal interests now-a-days. Dombek studied the synergistic
behavior of homogeneous ruthenium-rhodium catalysts for the
hydrogenation of CO to ethylene glycol.
[31]
From his study, it is
apparent that homogeneous solution of both ruthenium and
rhodium show excellent selectivity for CO reduction at
pressures from 400 to 850 atm and temperatures from 190° to
240° C. Miller et al.
[32]
examined the homogeneous hydro-
[a] T. Ash, Dr. T. Debnath, Prof. A. K. Das
School of Mathematical and Computational Sciences, Indian Association
for the Cultivation of Science, Jadavpur, Kolkata-700032, India
Tel.: + 91-33-2473-4971(ext.1257)
Fax: 91–33-24732805
E-mail: spakd@iacs.res.in
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW under
https://doi.org/10.1002/slct.201901767
Full Papers DOI: 10.1002/slct.201901767
10777 ChemistrySelect 2019, 4, 10777–10786 © 2019 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim