Observation of trapped-hole diffusion on the
surfaces of CdS nanorods
James K. Utterback, Amanda N. Grennell, Molly B. Wilker
†
, Orion M. Pearce, Joel D. Eaves
*
and Gordana Dukovic
*
In CdS nanocrystals, photoexcited holes rapidly become trapped at the particle surface. The dynamics of these trapped
holes have profound consequences for the photophysics and photochemistry of these materials. Using a combination of
transient absorption spectroscopy and theoretical modelling, we demonstrate that trapped holes in CdS nanorods are
mobile and execute a random walk at room temperature. In CdS nanorods of non-uniform width, we observe the
recombination of spatially separated electrons and trapped holes, which exhibits a t
-1/2
power-law decay at long times. A
one-dimensional diffusion–annihilation model describes the time-dependence of the recombination over four orders of
magnitude in time, from one nanosecond to ten microseconds, with a single adjustable parameter. We propose that
diffusive trapped-hole motion is a general phenomenon in CdS nanocrystals, but one that is normally obscured in
structures in which the wavefunctions of the electron and trapped hole spatially overlap. This phenomenon has important
implications for the oxidation photochemistry of CdS nanocrystals.
M
any novel properties of semiconducting nanostructures
emerge through the confinement of electronic wavefunc-
tions to small regions of space
1
. Cadmium-based chalco-
genide nanocrystals are some of the most widely studied and used
systems in nanoscience because synthetic control over particle
shape and size allows one to manipulate both electronic energies
and wavefunctions
1–3
. As a result of this tunability, there has been
a growing interest in using colloidal Cd–chalcogenide nanocrystals
for optoelectronic applications, such as solar energy conversion
4–8
.
Such technologies require control over the generation, separation
and extraction of photoexcited electrons and holes
6,8–11
. The
dynamics of these two carriers can differ substantially
10,12–15
. To
understand the principles that govern electron- and hole-relaxation
dynamics in these complex systems, models based on fundamental
physical phenomena are needed. However, the complicated shapes
of experimentally measured excited-state decay curves are often
elusive to simple kinetic models
14,15
.
In CdSe and CdS nanocrystals, photoexcited holes rapidly and
efficiently trap to localized states on the surface
10,12,13,15,16
. In nano-
scale CdS, in particular, hole trapping occurs on a picosecond time-
scale with >99% efficiency, so electrons primarily recombine with
trapped rather than with delocalized holes
10,12,13,17
. Consequently,
trapped holes play an integral role in excited-state dynamics
10,13,14,18
,
and the ability to harvest them is critical for applications such as
photovoltaics and solar photochemistry
17
. Despite their importance,
remarkably little is known about the nature of the trap states and the
dynamics of trapped holes
10,13,17,18
. The prevailing view is that the
trapped holes are localized spatially, which suggests that delocalized
electrons recombine with stationary holes
16–19
. There has not,
however, been direct evidence in support of this picture of recombi-
nation. If the energetically trapped holes were, instead, spatially
mobile, the governing picture of their relaxation dynamics would
fundamentally change.
Here, using transient absorption (TA) measurements on the sub-
picosecond to microsecond timescale in conjunction with theoreti-
cal modelling, we provide evidence that trapped holes on CdS
nanorod surfaces are not stationary. Instead, they execute a diffusive
random walk at room temperature. In CdS nanorods of
non-uniform width (non-uniform nanorods (NNRs)), excitation
wavelengths can be chosen such that photoexcited electrons dis-
sociate from trapped holes and localize to larger-diameter regions
of the NNRs with lower quantum confinement. TA experiments
that probe the relaxation of these localized electrons show a t
-1/2
power-law decay over two orders of magnitude in time, which
suggests a non-exponential recombination mechanism. In contrast,
in CdS quantum dots (QDs) and NNRs when the electron and
trapped hole are not separated spatially, the electron–hole recombi-
nation is exponential. These observations motivate an analytical
model for one-dimensional (1D) diffusion-limited electron–hole
recombination in the NNRs that fits the electron decay over four
orders of magnitude in time, from one nanosecond to ten micro-
seconds, with only one adjustable parameter. We propose that the
diffusive motion of trapped holes is a general phenomenon in
CdS nanocrystals that is normally obscured in structures in which
electron and trapped-hole wavefunctions remain spatially over-
lapped during the measurement of their recombination dynamics.
Finally, we illustrate how this fundamentally different picture of
the behaviour of trapped holes may impact the photochemistry of
CdS nanostructures.
Results and discussion
Power-law decay of spatially separated carriers. When a
photoexcited electron is delocalized over an entire CdS
nanocrystal, after hole trapping, the recombination behaviour is
insensitive to the location of the trapped hole. To examine
experimentally whether trapped holes can move on nanocrystal
surfaces, we use nanostructures with excited states that exhibit
spatial electron–hole separation and compare them with
structures in which the photoexcited electron and hole are not
separated. The synthesis of rod-shaped CdS nanocrystals results in
a mixture of nanorods with uniform and non-uniform widths
along their lengths
19
. These CdS NNRs provide a region in which
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, Colorado 80309, USA.
†
Present address: Department of Chemistry,
Luther College, Decorah, Iowa 52101, USA. *e-mail: gordana.dukovic@colorado.edu; joel.eaves@colorado.edu
ARTICLES
PUBLISHED ONLINE: 11 JULY 2016 | DOI: 10.1038/NCHEM.2566
NATURE CHEMISTRY | ADVANCE ONLINE PUBLICATION | www.nature.com/naturechemistry 1
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved