Forecasting the yield curve: A statistical model with market survey data
André Luís Leite
a
, Romeu Braz Pereira Gomes Filho
a
, José Valentim Machado Vicente
b,
⁎
a
Central Bank of Brazil, Brazil
b
Faculdades Ibmec-RJ and Central Bank of Brazil, Av. Presidente Vargas 730 7th Floor, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
abstract article info
Article history:
Received 12 June 2009
Received in revised form 1 December 2009
Accepted 1 February 2010
Available online 10 February 2010
JEL classification:
G1
E4
C5
Keywords:
Yield curve forecasting
Risk premium
Market surveys
In this paper we propose a statistical model to forecast the yield curve, using two major sources of information:
data from a market survey and the forward rate risk premium. We apply the model to forecast the Brazilian
yield curve six months ahead and compare the results with the well-known model of Diebold and Li (2006), a
random walk process and the predictions based on the forward rate. The proposed model produces accurate
forecasts and outperforms all the competitor models in terms of root mean square error (RMSE).
© 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
A tool to predict the yield curve is undoubtedly of great worth to
financial market analysts and investors. However, despite of the
relevance of this issue, few practical improvements have been made in
recent years. In this study we propose a parsimonious technique to
model the term structure of interest rates that relies on two
components: market survey data and the forward rate risk premium.
Then we use the proposed model to forecast the Brazilian domestic
yield curve using public data available on a daily basis. To the best of
our knowledge, there is no other article in the finance literature that
works with this approach applied to an emerging country.
1
Research into term structure of interest rates (TSIR) basically rests
on two classes of models, usually known as statistical models and
equilibrium models. In the first group the TSIR is constructed through
an interpolation process and forecasts are done using time series
models. In the second group, the models incorporate equilibrium
arguments, such as no-arbitrage, to analyze the TSIR, and forecasts are
produced by the dynamics implied in the model. Despite the lack of
economic theory grounds, statistical models are preferred in practical
problems due to their lesser estimation complexity.
2
To attain
computational simplicity, we use a statistical model in this paper.
3
Macroeconomic variables have been frequently used to analyze the
dynamics of interest rates. The Fischer equation (Fisher, 1930) and the
Taylor rule (Taylor, 1993) help make price indexes the main macroeco-
nomic variable used to model the TSIR, since they specify a direct relation
between inflation and interest rates.
4
On the other hand, some authors
find that market surveys are powerful predictors of future inflation (see,
for instance, Ang, Bekaert, & Wei, 2007; Mehra, 2002). To combine these
two features in single variable we use the inflation expectation calculated
by the Central Bank of Brazil (CBB) from a survey among professional
forecasters as the explanatory variable for future interest rates.
Campbell and Shiller (1991), Cochrane and Piazzesi (2005), Dai and
Singleton (2002), and Fama and Bliss (1987) analyze the failure of the
expectation hypothesis and the importance of time-varying risk
premia. Ludvigson and Ng (2007) find evidence that the interest rate
International Review of Financial Analysis 19 (2010) 108–112
⁎ Corresponding author. Tel.: + 55 21 2189 5762.
E-mail addresses: andreluis.leite@bcb.gov.br (A.L. Leite), romeu.gomes@bcb.gov.br
(R.B.P.G. Filho), jose.valentim@bcb.gov.br (J.V.M. Vicente).
1
Some recent papers deal with the prediction of the Brazilian yield curve. They
all use different approaches from ours. Among others, we can cite Almeida, Gomes,
Leite, and Vicente (2009), Lima, Luduvice, and Tabak (2006), and Vicente and Tabak
(2008).
2
Although Almeida and Vicente (2008) and Christensen, Diebold, and Rudebusch
(2008) present evidence in favor of the inclusion of no-arbitrage conditions when the
goal is to forecast interest rates, this issue is not without controversy, as shown by
Duffee (2008).
3
Although they are simpler to estimate, pure econometric models based on VAR or
ARMA processes have low predictive power of future interest rates, as shown by
Diebold and Li (2006) and Lima et al. (2006).
4
Among other works that use price indexes to model the term structure, we can cite
Ang and Piazzesi (2003), Diebold, Piazzesi, and Rudebusch (2005), Diebold,
Rudebusch, and Aruoba (2006), Hördahl, Tristani, and Vestin (2006) and Huse (2007).
1057-5219/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.irfa.2010.02.001
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
International Review of Financial Analysis