© JAPI • VOL. 56 • APRIL 2008 www.japi.org 237
Original Article#
Enteric Fever in Mumbai – Clinical Profle, Sensitivity
Patterns and Response to Antimicrobials
S Jog*, R Soman**, T Singhal***, C Rodrigues+, A Mehta+, FD Dastur**
Abstract
Aims : Enteric fever is endemic in Mumbai and its diagnosis poses several problems. Our main aim was
to study the clinical profle, haematological features of culture proven typhoid cases, the antimicrobial
susceptibility pattern of the isolates and the time to defervescence with the treatment received.
Material and Methods : This was a retospective chart review of all cases of culture proven enteric fever carried
out at a tertiary care private hospital in Mumbai over the period January 2003 to September 2005.
Results : Culture positivity in our study was 52.6%. Sixty one percent of the isolates were Salmonella typhi
while 39% were Salmonella paratyphi A. An absolute eosinopenia was seen in 76.9% of the patients. Before
being admitted to the hospital, 46.2% received antibiotics. The mean time to defervescence in patients who
received prior antibiotics was 4.5 days while that in those who did not receive prior antibiotics was 5.1
days.
Conclusions : A high culture positivity despite prior or ongoing antibiotic treatment was seen. Absolute
eosinophil count of 0% could be an important marker of typhoid. High prevalence of nalidixic acid resistance,
a marker of resistance to fuoroquinolones was observed. Combination treatment was not found to be superior
to treatment with a single antibiotic. ©
INTRODUCTION
E
nteric fever is a systemic illness caused by Salmonella
enterica serotype typhi or paratyphi A/B. In India the
disease is endemic with an incidence ranging from 102
to 2219 per 100,000 population.
1
It results in considerable
morbidity, absenteeism and resource utilization.
Diagnosis of enteric fever is fraught with problems.
History, physical findings and fever pattern are
suggestive but can neither confrm nor exclude typhoid.
Blood culture is the ‘gold standard’ for diagnosis and
also gives information about antibiotic sensitivity of the
isolate; however the cost of cultures, lack of “culture
of cultures” and administration of prior antibiotics
are impediments in this diagnostic approach. The
Widal test is very commonly used in Indian set up
but has very variable sensitivity and specifcity and
problems in interpretation. Therapy of enteric fever
is becoming more complicated and expensive with
time. By the end of 1990s, Salmonella enterica developed
resistance simultaneously to all frst line drugs like
chloramphenicol, cotrimoxazole and ampicillin.
*Fellow, Dept. of Infectious Diseases; **Consultant Physician;
***Consultant Paediatrician; +Consultant Microbiologist,
P.D.Hinduja National Hospital and Medical Research Centre, Veer
Savarkar Marg, Mahim, Mumbai 400016, India.
Received : 2.1.2007; Revised : 18.2.2008; Accepted : 3.3.2008
#Rapid Publication
Fluoroquinolones when frst introduced in early 1990’s
were very effective but the past decade has seen a
progressive increase in the MICs of ciprofoxacin and
high incidence of clinical failure to quinolones. The
beta lactams such as cefxime and ceftriaxone are now
being increasingly used but these are expensive drugs
and are associated with a long time to defervescence
and high rates of relapse. There have also been sporadic
reports of high-level resistance to ceftriaxone in S. typhi
and S. paratyphi.
2
Experience with new drugs such as
azithromycin is at present scanty.
5-7
To sum up, enteric fever raises several issues of
diagnosis and treatment. There is a scarcity of studies in
literature addressing these issues. Hence a retrospective
review of patients of enteric fever at our hospital was
carried out to solve some of these pertinent clinical
problems.
Aims and Objectives
The primary aim of the study was to study the
sensitivity patterns of S. enteritica and response to
antimicrobial therapy. The secondary aims were to
study the clinical and laboratory profle of patients with
culture proven enteric fever.
MATERIAL AND METHODS
This was a retrospective chart review of all cases
of enteric fever carried out at a tertiary care private