How optimistic do citizens
feel about digital contact
tracing? – Perspectives from
developing countries
Praveen S.V. and Rajesh Ittamalla
National Institute of Technology Tiruchirappalli, Tiruchirappalli, India, and
Dhilip Subramanian
Master of Analytics, Massey University, Wellington, New Zealand
Abstract
Purpose – Despite numerous positive aspects of digital contact tracing, the implied nature of contact
tracing is still viewed with skepticism. Those in favor of contact tracing often undermine various risks
involved with it, while those against it often undermine its positive benefits. However, unless the government
and the app makers can convince a significant section of the population to use digital contact apps, desired
results cannot be achieved. This study aims to focus on analyzing the perception of citizens belonging to
developing countries about digital contact tracing.
Design/methodology/approach – For this study, data were collected from Twitter. Tweets containing
hashtag and the word “contact tracing” were crawled using Python library Tweepy. Tweets across the top
five developing countries (India, Brazil, South Africa, Argentina and Columbia) with high COVID-19 cases
were collected for this study. After eliminating tweets of other languages, we selected 50,000 unique English
tweets for this study. Using the machine learning algorithm, we have detected the sentiment of all the tweets
belonging to each country. Structural topic modeling was performed for the tweets to understand the concerns
shared by citizens of the developing countries about digital contact tracing.
Findings – The study was conducted in two parts. Study 1 results show that Indians and Brazilians citizens
record more negative sentiments toward “digital contact tracing” than other major developing countries.
Surprisingly, the citizens of India and Brazil also records more positive sentiments about contact tracing. This
shows the polarized nature of the population of both countries while dealing with digital contact tracing.
Overall, only 33.3% of total tweets were positively related to contact tracing, while 53.7% of the total tweets
were neutral. Study 2 results show that factors such as the reliability of the contact tracing apps, contact
tracing may lead to unnecessary panic, invasion of privacy and data misuse as the prominent reasons why the
citizens of the five countries feel pessimistic about contact tracing.
Originality/value – After the COVID-19 strikes, numerous studies were conducted to analyze and suggest
the best possible way of implementing digital contact tracing to curb COVID. However, only a handful of
studies were conducted examining how the general public perceives the concept of digital contact tracing,
especially pertaining to developing countries. This study fills that gap.
Keywords Natural language processing, Python, COVID crises, R, Structural topic modeling
Paper type Research paper
1. Introduction
Even though we are just two months away from 2021, there are no signs of the COVID-19
crises decline. Many countries, especially developing countries, still record several
thousands of COVID-19 cases every day. Many experts cautioned the world governments
that COVID-19 is far from over, and it may even be there for another two years
Digital contact
tracing
Received 11 October 2020
Revised 11 October 2020
Accepted 11 October 2020
International Journal of Pervasive
Computing and Communications
© Emerald Publishing Limited
1742-7371
DOI 10.1108/IJPCC-10-2020-0166
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at:
https://www.emerald.com/insight/1742-7371.htm