Interpreting the Knowledge Map of Digital Library
Research (1990–2010)
Son Hoang Nguyen
Information & Knowledge Management, University of Technology Sydney, 15 Broadway, Ultimo, NSW 2007,
Australia, and Faculty of Information and Library Science, Vietnam National University, 336 NguyenTrai,
ThanhXuan, Hanoi, Vietnam. E-mail: n_hoangson@yahoo.com; Hoang.S.Nguyen@student.uts.edu.au
Gobinda Chowdhury
Information & Knowledge Management, University of Technology Sydney, 15 Broadway, Ultimo, NSW 2007,
Australia. E–mail: Gobinda.Chowdhury@uts.edu.au
A knowledge map of digital library (DL) research shows
the semantic organization of DL research topics and
also the evolution of the field. The research reported in
this article aims to find the core topics and subtopics of
DL research in order to build a knowledge map of the DL
domain. The methodology is comprised of a four-step
research process, and two knowledge organization
methods (classification and thesaurus building) were
used. A knowledge map covering 21 core topics and
1,015 subtopics of DL research was created and pro-
vides a systematic overview of DL research during the
last two decades (1990–2010). We argue that the map
can work as a knowledge platform to guide, evaluate,
and improve the activities of DL research, education,
and practices. Moreover, it can be transformed into a DL
ontology for various applications. The research method-
ology can be used to map any human knowledge
domain; it is a novel and scientific method for producing
comprehensive and systematic knowledge maps based
on literary warrant.
Introduction
Research and development activities in digital libraries
(DLs) have grown quite significantly in the last two decades,
drawing researchers and practitioners from a range of fields,
primarily computer science (63%) and library and informa-
tion studies (LIS) (26%) (Web of Knowledge, 2011). A
search of the Scopus database reveals a dramatic rise in the
number of publications (articles, papers, etc.) from 436
during the first decade (1990–1999) to 7,469 during the
second decade (2000–2010) (Scopus, 2011).
Because of its interdisciplinary nature, the field of DL
research involves a large number of topics and subtopics
which can be structured in a knowledge map to help
educators and researchers in exploring and understanding
the DL knowledge domain and its evolution. Nguyen and
Chowdhury (2011) reported on research that aimed to build
a DL knowledge map, but due to space limitations they
could only report briefly on the study’s methods and list
some major DL topics and subtopics. This article reports on
that research, providing the research background, details
of the methodology, and the full DL knowledge map with
interpretations.
Literature Review
Knowledge Mapping
Geographically speaking, a knowledge map or a naviga-
tion map is a visual representation of an area that provides a
symbolic depiction highlighting relationships between ele-
ments of that space such as objects, regions, and themes
(Njue, 2010). Road maps are regularly used by travellers on
land, sailors use their charts when they go to sea, and
scientists often rely on spatial knowledge maps when they
practice science. Likewise, semantic or word-based knowl-
edge maps are often used by students, teachers, and
researchers as learning, teaching, knowledge navigation, and
assessment tools (Fisher, Wandersee, & Moody 2002). In
general, a knowledge map may be considered as a knowl-
edge “yellow pages” or a cleverly constructed database
pointing to knowledge (Zins, 2007b). It is a guide, not a
repository (Davenport & Prusak, 1998).
The idea of knowledge mapping in the knowledge man-
agement field can be analogous to the use of concept maps
and concept mapping. According to Lanzing ( 1997), concept
Received April 3, 2012; revised September 7, 2012; accepted September 7,
2012
© 2013 ASIS&T
•
Published online in Wiley Online Library
(wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI: 10.1002/asi.22830
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN SOCIETY FOR INFORMATION SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY, ••(••):••–••, 2013