PHYSICAL REVIEW A 82, 063618 (2010)
Application of the static fluctuation approximation to the computation of the thermodynamic
properties of an interacting trapped two-dimensional hard-sphere Bose gas
Asaad R. Sakhel,
1
Saleem I. Qashou,
3
Roger R. Sakhel,
2
and Humam B. Ghassib
4
1
Al-Balqa Applied University, Faculty of Engineering Technology, Amman 11134, Jordan
2
Department of Basic Sciences, Faculty of Information Technology, Al-Isra University, Amman 11622, Jordan
3
Department of Physics, Faculty of Science and Information Technology, Zarqa Private University, Zarqa 13132, Jordan
4
Department of Physics, The University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan
(Received 19 June 2010; published 14 December 2010)
The static fluctuation approximation (SFA) is applied to compute the thermodynamic properties of a trapped
two-dimensional (2D) interacting hard-sphere (HS) Bose gas in the weakly and strongly interacting regime. A
mean-field approach involving a variational wave function is used to compute the mean-field energy as a function
of temperature for each harmonic oscillator (HO) state plugged into the SFA technique. In the variational
approach, a parameter α is introduced into the harmonic oscillator wave function in order to take into account the
changes in the width when the repulsive interactions between the bosons are increased. In the weakly interacting
regime, below the critical temperature, the total energy of all HO states (evaluated by our model) matches the non-
interacting result very well. However, beyond the critical temperature, we “fit” our energies to the classical limit
for 2D bosons in a trap by using a suitably proposed weighting function. We compare our results to earlier results
of mean-field theory. Further, we evaluate the density matrix arising from correlations between the HO orbitals.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevA.82.063618 PACS number(s): 67.85.−d, 05.70.Ce, 03.75.Hh
I. INTRODUCTION
The trapped two-dimensional (2D) interacting Bose gas
presents many challenges. The evaluation of the thermody-
namic properties represents just one of these challenges. It
is not a straightforward matter and usually requires path-
integral Monte Carlo (PIMC) calculations. In addition, many
properties of 2D trapped Bose gases have yet to be explored
both experimentally and theoretically [1]; various problems
remain open [2], such as the estimation of the BEC transition
temperature in a 2D interacting system and the explicit rela-
tionship between superfluidity and the quasicondensate. Two-
dimensional systems have generally become very interesting,
thanks to the interplay between BEC and Kosterlitz-Thouless
transitions and other issues [3]. It is therefore in order to
develop methods for exploring such systems.
Various methods and techniques have been used to investi-
gate the trapped 2D Bose gas. Variational methods [3,4], the
classical-field simulation technique [5], path-integral Monte
Carlo methods [1,6,7], as well as Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov
theory [8] have all been applied. For example, Nho and Landau
[1] used a finite-temperature PIMC method and showed that
BEC can form at finite temperature. In order to perform
their calculations, they used only N = 27 hard-sphere bosons,
because a larger number required an extensive amount of
computational time.
In this article, our chief goal is to demonstrate an application
of the static fluctuation approximation (SFA) [9,10] in an
evaluation of the thermodynamic properties of a trapped,
2D hard-sphere (HS) Bose gas and to compare to the
corresponding 3D properties. Comparisons are also made with
corresponding 2D analytical results for the thermodynamic
properties. The relative advantage of the SFA is that it can
yield the thermodynamic properties of a system for a broad
range of temperature in one single calculation. One can
obtain easily using the SFA, the energy fluctuations, number
fluctuations, and thermodynamic properties, all as functions
of temperature. The SFA particularly invokes the role of the
energy fluctuations in the determination of the thermodynamic
properties. It essentially corrects for any approximations done
in the mean-field evaluation of the energy via the energy
fluctuations. This corrected energy is then incorporated into
the thermodynamic potential ln Q, where Q is the grand
canonical partition function from which all the thermodynamic
properties are evaluated. In addition, the SFA can handle a
large number of particles up to N ∼ 1000. On the other hand,
in other methods such as PIMC calculations, one can obtain the
thermodynamic properties for one temperature at a time only,
i.e., point by point. However, the SFA is limited in that it fails
at very strong interactions g> 0.01, whereas other methods,
such as PIMC calculations, are excellent in this regard as they
can deal with strongly interacting systems. The SFA works
very well mainly in the weakly to strongly interacting regime
up to g = 0.01.
Some of the properties we evaluate have been—to our
knowledge—rarely addressed in the literature, such as the
thermal behavior of the energy for each harmonic oscillator
(HO) state m and the number fluctuations 〈(
ˆ
N
m
)
2
〉. Another
goal is to shed more light on the effects of dimensionality on
such systems by comparing 2D to 3D.
We thus consider N hard-sphere bosons in a 2D harmonic
trap in a broad range of temperature T . The interactions be-
tween the bosons are modelled by a δ function pseudopotential.
The energies for each HO state are evaluated using many-body
mean-field theory, and the thermodynamic properties are
obtained using SFA in 2D, applied earlier [11] to the 3D
trapped interacting Bose gas. It should be emphasized that,
with the SFA method applied here, we are able to use a large
number of particles, N = 1000. It should also be emphasized
that our goal is not to provide a method for computing the
energies but rather to obtain them for use in SFA. Nevertheless,
the mean-field model we present gives the energies accurately
in the condensate regime below the transition temperature but
1050-2947/2010/82(6)/063618(16) 063618-1 ©2010 The American Physical Society