Design techniques for cogging
torque reduction in a fractional-
slot PMBLDC motor
Lidija Petkovska
Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Information Technologies,
Ss Cyril and Methodius University in Skopje, Skopje, Macedonia
Paul Lefley
School of Engineering, University of Leicester, Leicester, UK, and
Goga Vladimir Cvetkovski
Faculty of Electrical Engineering and Information Technologies,
Ss Cyril and Methodius University in Skopje, Skopje, Macedonia
Abstract
Purpose – This paper presents the design techniques applied to a novel fractional-slot 6/4 pole permanent
magnet brushless direct current (PMBLDC) motor, for cogging torque reduction. The notable feature of this
motor is the simplicity of the design and low production cost. The purpose of this paper is to reduce the peak
cogging torque of the motor. The focus is put on the stator topology tuning, and a new design for the stator
poles is proposed. By determining the optimum stator pole arc length and the best pole shoe thickness, the
cogging torque is significantly reduced. This new optimised motor design has been analysed in detail. The
validation of the results is documented with respective figures and charts.
Design/methodology/approach – At the beginning, the design data for the 6/4 pole PMBLDC motor
with concentrated three phase windings and asymmetric stator pole arcs is presented. In the study, this motor
is taken as a reference model (A
0
, T
0
). A full performance finite element analysis of the reference motor has
been carried out, and the weak points in the motor design have been identified. By simple design techniques,
tuning the stator pole geometry, a two-stage design optimisation for cogging torque minimisation has been
performed and the solution array has been derived. The optimised model is selected and proposed (A
opt
, T
opt
).
The comparative analysis of the reference and optimised motors show the advantages of the proposed novel
design and prove the methodology.
Findings – The results of the work demonstrate how simple design techniques can minimise the peak
of the cogging torque profile, while maintaining the specified electromagnetic torque value. The
sensitivity of the cogging torque profile because of changes of the stator pole design inside the
prescribed constraints is apparent. The stator poles of the reference motor have an arc length of 85° and
pole shoe thickness of 6 mm. The newly shaped stator poles have an arc length of 78.5° and pole shoe
thickness 4.8 mm. The peak-cogging torque has been reduced from 0.158 Nm to a respectable value of
0.066 Nm. However, to reduce electromagnetic torque ripple and pulsations, further investigations are
required.
Originality/value – The paper presents an approach to cogging torque reduction for a 6/4 PMBLDC
motor. A two-step original design procedure is introduced and an optimised stator pole geometry is defined.
The minimised cogging torque has been demonstrated with improved usage of the active materials. This
work could serve as a good basis for further optimisation of the motor design.
Keywords Permanent magnet machine, Finite element analysis, Shape optimisation, Optimisation,
Design optimisation methodology, Torque calculation, PM brushless DC motor, Asymmetric motor,
Fractional-slot motor, Cogging torque, Electromagnetic torque, Torque ripple
Paper type Research paper
Cogging
torque
reduction
Received 11 January 2020
Revised 12 April 2020
Accepted 13 April 2020
COMPEL - The international
journal for computation and
mathematics in electrical and
electronic engineering
© Emerald Publishing Limited
0332-1649
DOI 10.1108/COMPEL-01-2020-0015
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at:
https://www.emerald.com/insight/0332-1649.htm