The many ways of speaking as ‘I’: Wuna Wu’s first-person
documentaries from Taiwan
Tze-lan Deborah Sang
Department of Linguistics and Germanic, Slavic, Asian and African Languages, Michigan State University, East
Lansing, MI, USA
ABSTRACT
Touted as a representative of the ‘Me’ generation of documentary
makers in twenty-first-century Taiwan, Wuna Wu has appeared as
both filmmaker and social actor in her documentaries. Even when
the ostensible subject matter of the film is not Wu, she has often
inserted herself into the story and the frame. This raises questions
of why she elects to be visible to the documentary viewer, what
her visibility and performativity in front of the camera allows her
to achieve, and what she gains by using a first-person voiceover
narration. This essay examines Wu’s first-person positioning in
three prize-winning documentaries: Happy or Not (2002), Farewell
1999 (2003) and Let’s Fall in Love (2008) and argues that she has
experimented with a wide variety of first-person positionings,
ranging from that which renders her vulnerable to that which self-
empowers. Her diverse first-person approaches underscore the
question of documentary ethics, the importance of mediation for
self-identity, and the opportunities for building sociality and
community through documentary. Her first-person films bring out
the interconnectedness between self and other, providing a
window on the residual effects, in modern Taiwan, of the
Confucian concept of the self as relationally defined.
KEYWORDS
Taiwanese women’s
documentary; documentary
ethics; gender & sexuality;
subjectivity; Confucianism;
globalization
Touted as a representative of the ‘Me’ generation of documentary makers in twenty-first-
century Taiwan (Wen 2008; Kuo 2012; Berry 2018), Wuna Wu has appeared as both
filmmaker and a social actor in several of her documentaries. Even when the ostensible
subject matter of the film is not Wu, she has often inserted herself into the story and
the frame. This raises a number of questions: If Wu could have chosen to stay behind
the camera or perhaps excised the visual traces of her presence at the filming location
through editing, why did she elect to be visible to the documentary viewer? What do
her visibility and performativity in front of the camera allow her to achieve? And what
does she gain by using the first-person voice, rather than a disembodied third-person in
voiceover narration?
This essay examines Wu’s first-person positioning in three of her most acclaimed docu-
mentaries: Happy or Not (2002), Farewell 1999 (2003) and Let’s Fall in Love (2008a). The
first two won prestigious Taipei Film Festival awards whereas the last succeeded in gaining
a commercial release in theatres, a feat achieved by only a tiny minority of Taiwanese
© 2020 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group
CONTACT Tze-lan Deborah Sang tzelan@msu.edu Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA
STUDIES IN DOCUMENTARY FILM
2020, VOL. 14, NO. 1, 63–80
https://doi.org/10.1080/17503280.2020.1720093