PAUL BOWLES
1
ASSESSING THE IMPACT OF PROPOSED BANK MERGERS
ON RURAL COMMUNITIES: A CASE STUDY OF BRITISH
COLUMBIA
(Accepted 10 January, 1999)
ABSTRACT. The restructuring of financial markets and financial institutions
through bank mergers has been accompanied in many countries by concerns about
the resulting ‘geography of finance’. In Canada, two proposed mergers involving
four of the largest banks have raised concerns about the possible impacts of the
proposed mergers on the access to financial institutions in rural Canada. This
paper assesses the potential impact of the proposed mergers on the geography of
finance in rural communities in British Columbia. The methodological choices
which must be made to frame such an anlysis are discussed and include choices
related to the definitions of ‘accessibility’, the ‘industry’, a ‘competitive industry’,
a ‘bank branch’ and a ‘community’. A new Index is devised to measure the vulner-
ability of rural communities to post-merger bank branch closures. It is concluded
that the bank mergers will, if approved, have significant negative impacts for the
accessibility of the banking system in rural British Columbia. It is also suggested
that Canada needs to examine establishing a wider regulatory framework which
addresses the issue of accessibility on a longer term basis.
I. INTRODUCTION
Financial markets and financial institutions are being restructured
throughout the world. In some countries, notably, in Russia and
in Asia, such restructuring is taking place in the face on financial
instability and the threat of financial collapse. In other countries,
such as those in North America and in Europe, restructuring is
taking place in response to deregulation and global competitive
pressures. In these latter countries, much of this restructuring is
taking place through the rationalisation of banking activities through
bank mergers. In the U.S., for example, there were over 6 300 bank
mergers between 1980 and 1994 and more have been announced
since partly as a result of the passage of the Branch Banking and
Social Indicators Research 51: 17–40, 2000.
© 2000 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.