207 © Springer International Publishing AG 2017
J.C. Carey et al. (eds.), International Handbook for Policy Research on School-Based Counseling,
DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-58179-8_13
Using Qualitative Methods
to Evaluate Policy Implementation
in School-Based Counseling
Alfred A. Adegoke and Foluke N. Bolu-Steve
Introduction and Background
The need to reposition school-based counselling
to meet the challenges of the twenty-first-century
system of education is imperative in Africa in
particular and around the globe in general. Policy
and policy research related directly to school-
based counselling around the globe are relatively
scarce (Carey, 2016; Nakamura 1887). This is
due largely to the fact that many countries of the
world do not seem to appreciate the connections
between school-based counselling and national
priorities. In addition, the educational policies of
most countries seem to be what determines the
direction and quality of school-based counselling
in such countries. In Nigeria, for instance, until
recently when an attempt is being made to
develop a framework for guidance and counsel-
ling services in Nigerian schools, only a terse
statement was made on guidance and counselling
in the national policy on education (Aluede,
Iyamu, Adubale, & Oramah, 2017).
According to Harris (2013), school-based
counselling around the world shows great vari-
ability in terms of focus, role, training, and mod-
els. The school child in many African countries,
for instance, has many challenges arising from
his fast-changing environment, thus making
adjustment difficult. The present-day educational
system in many African countries is faced with
many challenges such as poorly motivated teach-
ers and students, lack of infrastructure, poor
funding, policy summersaults by successive gov-
ernments, etc. If, however, school-based counsel-
ling is properly conceived and implemented in
each country of the world, it can serve as a tool to
enhance the total development of learners. Hence,
there is the need for a more holistic and well-
articulated school-based counselling programs
for school children around the world.
Qualitative research methods constitute a very
important mechanism for evaluating policy
implementation in Africa as well as other parts of
the world. Qualitative methodology is a system-
atic subjective approach that involves gathering
of information that is not necessarily in numeri-
cal form Denzin & Lincoln (2000). Although in
most situations, numbers are necessary for analy-
sis, qualitative methods can provide in-depth
information that is not possible with quantitative
methods. Qualitative methods are useful in gath-
ering comprehensive information on how people
feel and think about a particular program or
activity. Qualitative methods involve a correct
description of participant responses; this helps
evaluators to gain insight into the life experi-
ences of a group of people and at the same time
to be able to give meaning to those experiences.
A.A. Adegoke, PhD (*) • F.N. Bolu-Steve, PhD
Department of Counselor Education, University of
Ilorin, Ilorin, Nigeria
e-mail: fredgoke2@yahoo.com; bolusteve2002@
yahoo.com
13