Child's Nerv Syst (1994) 10:321-327
© Springer-Verlag 1994
Concezio Di Rocco
Enrico Marchese
Francesco Velardi
A survey of the first complication
of newly implanted CSF shunt devices for
the treatment of nontumoral hydrocephalus
Cooperative survey of the 1991-1992
Education Committee of the ISPN
Received: 3 January 1994
C. Di Rocco (~) . E. Marchese • tv. Velardi
Pediatric Section,
Institute of Neurosurgery,
Catholic University,
Largo A. Gemelli, 8,
1-00168 Rome, Italy
Abstract The results of an interna-
tional multicenter study concerning
the first complication of newly im-
planted cerebrospinal fluid shunts
in nontumoral hydrocephalus are
the subject of the present report.
The authors have collected infor-
mation on 773 cases from four con-
tinents. In particular, the following
data were evaluated in relation to
the general incidence of complica-
tions recorded in the first follow-up
year: the patient's age at the opera-
tion, the etiology of hydrocephalus,
the type of CSF shunt device used,
and the modality of the surgical
procedures. The overall complica-
tion rate in the series was 29%.
Age and etiology of hydrocephalus
appear to play a major role in in-
fluencing the complication rate; on
the other hand, the choice of a
specific CSF shunt device seems to
be less important in this respect.
Key words Nontumoral
hydrocephalus • CSF shunt devices
CSF shunt complication
Introduction
At the invitation of the Education Committee of the
ISPN, 38 neurosurgical centers agreed to participate in a
cooperative study that aimed to evaluate the causes and
respective incidences of the first complications of cere-
brospinal fluid (CSF) shunting in patients with nontu-
moral hydrocephalus operated on for the first time dur-
ing 1991 and followed for at least 1 year.
In addition, the study was planned to provide general
information about policies of hydrocephalus treatment in
neurosurgical centers around the world, e.g., which type
of CSF shunt procedure was most frequently used, which
shunt devices were selected, and what collateral measures
adopted to reduce the risk of shunt failure.
Materials and methods
A "Prospective Evaluation Form for Hydrocephalus" was sent to
all members of the ISPN. Thirty-eight centers agreed to participate
(see Appendix). The Coordinating Centre (Rome, Section of Pedi-
atric Neurosurgery, Catholic University, School of Medicine) re-
ceived a total of 830 forms, 773 of which were considered eligible for
the study. The remaining 57 could not be utilized because they
contained insufficient information or reported on ineligible cases
(e.g., patients with tumoral hydrocephalus). Although some forms
were not completely filled out and the statistical figures relating to
the different aspects of the inquiry varied, this was only to an extent
so small as not to affect the overall analysis.
Participating centers were in four main areas of the world:
The Americas (389 patients; 50.4%)
Europe (367 patients; 47.4%)
Oceania (12 patients; 1.5%)
Africa (5 patients; 0.7%)
Male patients outnumbered female patients (430 vs 340); in 3 cases
the sex was not specified. The overall mean age at operation was 3
years, with a range from 1 day to 83 years (Fig. 1). However, 38%
of patients were operated on at less than 1 month of age, 35%
between 1 and 6 months, 14% between 6 months and 2 years, and
10% between 2 and 18 years - accounting for 97% in all. The small
percentage of adult subjects (3%) were considered a useful inclusion
in this study for comparative purposes.
It is worth noting that in 23% of cases the diagnosis of hydro-
cephalus was obtained antenatally by ultrasonography.