© IEOM Society
Apartment Building Management Performance Assessment Using
Data Envelopment Analysis
Wei Tong Chen and Jien-Bin Jian
Department of Construction Engineering
National Yunlin University of Science and Technology
Touliu, Yunlin 640, Taiwan
chenwt@yuntech.edu.tw, jimmy74712@gmail.com
Hong Long Chen
Department of Business and Management
National University of Tainan
Tainan, 700, Taiwan
along314@mail.nutn.edu.tw
Abstract
This study reviews improvement of operations and decision making through the utilization of data envelopment
analysis (DEA) to assess the operational efficiency of 24 apartment buildings based on four dimensions: operations
finance, management systems, service quality and personnel quality. Eight items are used to assess case operational
efficiency and five output items are obtained. It is found that the total efficiency typically averaged more than 90%
for the four dimensions used to evaluate case efficiency. Personnel quality made little contribution to Decision
Making Unit (DMU) efficiency. The optimal efficiency for each dimension was found in DMU09 (operational
finance), DMU23 (management system), DMU22 (service quality) and DMU18 (personnel quality). DMU10 is
considered the benchmark case while DMU23 is the least ideal and most in need of improvement.
Keywords
Apartment building, performance assessment, data envelopment analysis
1. Introduction
Apartment building management requires integrating a variety of business operations and services, and is a
fundamental key service industry with considerable output value and employment effects. The management and
execution of these business items requires the attention of a professional team. In Taiwan, apartment building
management firms (ABMFs) are typically selected by tender, and determination of whether to extend the contract
for the following year is made through irregular on-site performance assessments by the management committee
accompanied by management firm executives. This type of assessment method is easily influenced by the subjective
opinions of the resident management committee members or the management firm executives, and does not easily
reflect actual objective conditions. Therefore, Taiwan’s ABMFs face a serious challenge in establishing an objective
and reasonable comparison mechanism based on objective field data analysis as the basis for performance
assessment. Such a mechanism would establish performance benchmarks, identify areas of poor performance and
assist the organization in improving overall operating performance.
Performance assessment not only allows for an understanding of employee contributions, but also provides insight
into the degree to which an organization has realized its goals, thus providing solutions for assessing the
effectiveness of human resource allocation and the organization’s strategic development process. Assessing staff
performance provides managers with information required to achieve the organization’s goals and improve
management deficiencies.
Through mathematical modeling of inputs and outputs, data envelopment analysis (DEA) calculates production
boundaries as the basic measurement of efficiency, citing the concept of the production function in executing
efficiency assessment. DEA is widely used in various industrial sectors including sewage treatment plants (Ramón
Proceedings of the 2015 International Conference on Operations Excellence and Service Engineering
Orlando, Florida, USA, September 10-11, 2015
110