Research Paper
Environmental assessment of underdrain designs
for a sand media filter
Josep Bov
e, Joan Pujol, Gerard Arbat, Miquel Duran-Ros,
Francisco Ramı´rez de Cartagena, Jaume Puig-Bargu
es
*
Department of Chemical and Agricultural Engineering and Technology, University of Girona, C/Maria Aur elia
Capmany 61, 17003 Girona, Spain
article info
Article history:
Received 31 July 2017
Received in revised form
8 January 2018
Accepted 11 January 2018
Keywords:
Drip irrigation
Clogging
Filtration
Computational fluid dynamics
Optimal design
Life cycle assessment
Increasing energy demand is the main problem linked with the adoption of more efficient
irrigation techniques, particularly microirrigation. In microirrigation systems, important
pressure losses and therefore energy consumption, occur at the filters, which are a key
component in preventing emitter clogging. Previous studies have shown that the main
pressure drop across sand media filters, which are widely used in microirrigation, occurs in
the underdrain elements. To minimise this problem, new underdrains should be designed
but an issue is how their environmental impact can be reduced. Two alternative design
strategies were found: firstly, keeping the original filter dimensions and reducing energy
consumption during operation by 30%; and, secondly, reducing filter size and reducing
construction material by 25% but keeping the original pressure losses. A life cycle
assessment transforming environmental effects into monetary values was carried out
comparing a commercial sand filter with the two filters designed following the two
aforementioned strategies. Results show that both alternatives reduce the environmental
impact of the sand commercial filter. Reduction of filter size is the optimum strategy if
filtered volumes are below 63,000 m
3
along the filter life, while reduction of energy con-
sumption was the best alternative for higher filtered volumes. This work shows the use-
fulness of life cycle assessment for assessing design strategies that could improve the
sustainability of microirrigation equipment.
© 2018 IAgrE. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Over the last 50 years, world agricultural production has
grown to between 2.5 and 3 times, while the cultivated area
has grown only by 12%. More than 40% of the increase in food
production has come from irrigated areas, which have
doubled in area. Over the same period, the cultivated area per
person has gradually declined to less than 0.25 ha, a clear
indicator of agricultural intensification. Irrigated agriculture
currently uses 2.2% of the world's land surface and accounts
for 70% of all water withdrawn from aquifers, streams and
lakes (FAO, 2011). Within this context, irrigation sustainability
assessment is important, especially in areas where rainfall is
scarce and/or irregular. For example, Costa et al. (2016) noted
that water is considered the most important and valuable
resource in the Mediterranean basin. With the objective of
increasing water use efficiency, a common strategy has been
* Corresponding author. Fax: þ34 972 41 83 99.
E-mail address: jaume.puig@udg.edu (J. Puig-Bargu es).
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/issn/15375110
biosystems engineering 167 (2018) 126 e136
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.biosystemseng.2018.01.005
1537-5110/© 2018 IAgrE. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.