Electrochemical properties of corrosion products formed
on Zn-Mg, Zn-Al and Zn-Al-Mg coatings in model
atmospheric conditions
J. Stoulil*, T. Prosek, A. Nazarov, J. Oswald, P. Kriz and
D. Thierry
The electrochemical properties of corrosion products formed under sodium
chloride deposits on zinc coatings alloyed with aluminium and magnesium
have been studied using impedance spectroscopy (EIS), scanning Kelvin probe
(SKP) and photoluminescence (PL) techniques. The low-energy band gap
identifed in corrosion products on hot-dip galvanized steel was associated with
their higher electric conductivity and ef fciency of the rate-controlling oxygen
reduction reaction. It was attributed to the presence of ZnO, zincite. The
formation of ZnO was hindered by the alloying. The alloyed coatings were
covered by more compact layers of corrosion products with lower electric
conductivity and better barrier properties.
1 Introduction
Hot-dip zinc coatings alloyed with aluminium such as Zn-5Al
and Zn-55Al have been used for industrial applications since
decades. New coating alternatives containing magnesium with
substantially reduced corrosion rates compared to hot dip
galvanized (HDG) steel have recently emerged [1–4]. A number
of explanations of the inhibiting effect of magnesium have been
proposed. Mg is known to provide a complex microstructure.
Large potential differences of up to 0.5 V [5] between the phases
may be observed for Zn-Al coatings with a multiphase structure,
where Zn-rich phases are preferentially attacked by corrosion.
This effect may be intensifed in the presence of oxidising agents,
e.g. nitrates [6]. The potential difference is shrinking in the
presence of chlorides that activate the phases rich in Al [7].
Tanaka et al. reported substantial refnement of the structure
of Zn-6Al coating after addition of Mg and Si, which made
corrosion much more uniform [8]. Higher homogeneity after
addition of Mg was also observed by Li et al. [9]. Erdavan et al.
noted that a Zn-Al-Mg coating worked better as a sacrifcial
electrode than a Zn-Al coating [10], probably due to the higher
dissolution rate of the former coating.
With respect to Zn-Al-Mg coatings, Mg is primarily
dissolved; later, Al also dissolved at alkalinized cathodic
sites [11]. A detailed mechanism of the action of magnesium
in a chloride cyclic corrosion test was suggested by Hosking
et al. [1]. Released Mg
2þ
ions migrated to cathodic sites and
buffered them by the formation of Mg(OH)
2
. This allowed a
compact layer of simonkolleite, Zn
5
Cl
2
(OH)
8
.H
2
O, to spread
from anodic locations over the whole surface. Simonkolleite is
otherwise unstable at higher pH levels. This phenomenon was
later confrmed by titration experiments performed by Volovitch
et al. [12]. On the contrary, while monitoring binary Zn-Mg
alloys, Prosek et al. reported the lowest corrosion losses for zinc
alloys with 4–8 wt.% of Mg, the surface of which was almost
exclusively covered by hydrozincite, Zn
5
(OH)
6
(CO
3
)
2
, after
exposure under non-rinsing conditions under chloride depos-
its [13]. Schuerz et al. consider hydrotalcite (LDH), Zn
6
Al
2
(CO
3
)
(OH)
16
.4H
2
O, to be the key corrosion product in the corrosion
protection of Zn-Al-Mg coatings [14]. Similarly arranged
layered structures were also reported by Volovitch et al. [11]
and described in details by Persson et al. [15]. Keppert et al.
studied an infuence of pH on composition of corrosion
products [16,17] and an infuence of presence of other
anions [18].
Volovitch et al. noted bonding and removal of CO
2
and SO
2
4
from the corrosion environment [11] as one of the positive role of
magnesium, which is, however, in confict with the generally
perceived positive infuence of CO
2
on the corrosion of Zn alloys,
J. Stoulil
Institute of Chemical Technology, Technicka ´ 5, 166 28 Prague, Czech
Republic
E-mail: jan.stoulil@vscht.cz
T. Prosek, A. Nazarov, D. Thierry
Institut de la Corrosion/French Corrosion Institute, 220, rue Pierre
Rivoalon, F-29200 Brest, (France)
J. Oswald
Institute of Physics, Czech Academy of Science, Cukrovarnicka ´ 10/112,
162 00 Prague 6, (Czech Republic)
P. Kriz
University of South Bohemia, Jeronymova 10, 371 15
Ceske ´ Bude ˇjo-
vice, (Czech Republic)
Materials and Corrosion 2015, XXX, No. XXX DOI: 10.1002/maco.201408058 1
www.matcorr.com wileyonlinelibrary.com © 2015 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim