Int. J. Educ. Stud. 02 (01) 2015. 25-36
25
Available Online at ESci Journals
International Journal of Educational Studies
ISSN: 2305-106X (Online), 2306-1650 (Print)
http://www.escijournals.net/IJES
THE DEVELOPMENT OF A CAPACITY-ANALYSIS PARADIGM FOR THE SENIOR HIGH
SCHOOL ECONOMICS TEACHER’S PROFESSIONAL IDENTITY IN GHANA
Mumuni B. Yidana, Raheem A. Lawal
Department of Arts and Social Sciences Education, University of Cape Coast, Ghana.
Department of Arts and Social Sciences Education, University of Ilorin, Nigeria.
A B S T R A C T
This study developed a set of core professional identity indicators to which professional Economics teachers
and Economics teacher educators in Ghana responded in order to determine their validity as components of
the Economics teachers’ professional identity in relation to their ideal professional capacity. In specific terms,
the study investigated opinions of respondents on the importance attached to the rubrics of teacher s’
professional capacity as well as differences in opinion on the importance placed on indicators of teachers’
professional knowledge, values, skills and reflective practice. The study was a descriptive type which
employed the survey method. The study sample comprised 751 professional Economics teachers and 125
Economics teacher educators who were selected through the simple random sampling technique. One self-
developed instrument, Questionnaire on Senior High School Economics Teachers’ Identity (QSHSETI) was used
and a reliability index of 0.96 was obtained. The data were analyzed using mean and the independent sample
t- test. There are three paradigmatic levels for considering teachers’ identity. They are the ideal paradigm as
shown in Figure 1, the implementable paradigm as obtained by the researcher-developed instrument, and
finally the perceived or realistic paradigm based on the consensus of Economics teacher educators and
Economics teachers. The findings of this study revealed discrepancies in opinion between the perceived
competency and ideal targets of Economics teacher educators and that of Economics teachers. Curriculum
development in Economics teacher education should therefore aim at bridging the gap between the ideal
competency targets and the perceived or core competency targets. The study concluded that, teacher
education policy makers should support continuous capacity-building programs among Economics teachers
and Economics teacher educators.
Keywords: Economics teacher, economics teacher educator, professional capacity, curriculum development.
INTRODUCTION
There are competing perspectives on what constitutes an
ideal teacher. Lawal (2006) identifies four broad
attributes of an effective English teacher as; professional
knowledge, values, skills and reflective practice. To him,
these attributes are characteristics of an ideal English
teacher. A widely accepted claim in the science and
mathematics community is the constructivist idea of
discovery learning as opposed to direct instruction, which
is the best way to get deep and lasting understanding of
scientific phenomena and procedures (Klahr and Nigam,
2004). Consequently, Staver (2007) proposes the
following instructional practices as identity indicators of
effective science teachers: Demonstrating mastery of
subject matter, respecting and accepting the unique
perceptions of individual learners, reflecting on, and
considering learners’ prior knowledge when selecting
teaching strategies and techniques. Other instructional
practices and attributes are; committed to the teaching of
the subject, a belief in one’s ability to influence students’
learning outcomes and creating a non-threatening,
learning environment. These are Staver’s perspectives of
an ideal science teacher. Latterell (2010) reports that a
good mathematics teacher has knowledge in the subject
matter, is able to engage and motivate students, has
effective management skills and emphasizes
understanding over rote procedures.
Available Online at ESci Journals
International Journal of Educational Studies
ISSN: 2312-458X (Online), 2312-4598 (Print)
http://www.escijournals.net/IJES
* Corresponding Author:
Email: mbyidana@yahoo.com
© 2015 ESci Journals Publishing. All rights reserved.