Fuzzy probabilistic approach for
risk assessment of BOT toll roads
in Indian context
Tirth Dineshkumar Patel
Department of Civil Engineering, U.V. Patel College of Engineering,
Mehsana, India
Theo C. Haupt
Department of Engineering, Mangosuthu University of Technology,
Scottburgh, South Africa, and
Tejas Bhatt
Department of Bio-Medical Engineering, U.V. Patel College of Engineering,
Ganpat University, Mehsana, India
Abstract
Purpose – The built-transfer and operate (BOT) toll model has been a common approach for highway
construction in India. Due to large amount of investment, many stakeholders and long concession period,
Indian BOT toll roads become susceptible to different risks. Risk assessment is one of the essential and
difficult steps of risk management that enables professionals to quantify and analyze the risks that may
hamper the BOT toll project performance in terms of cost, quality, safety and time. The purpose of this study
is to identify and assess the risk factors by the fuzzy probabilistic model.
Design/methodology/approach – The comprehensive literature review has been carried out for
identification of Indian BOT toll roads projects’ risk factors. A structured questionnaire was prepared which
was then filled by contractors, government officers, academicians, project managers and consultants. For risk
assessment, a systematic quantitative-based fuzzy probabilistic model is proposed with the help of lab-view,
as a risk assessment technique to simulate the impreciseness of human judgment and to improve the
assessment accuracy.
Findings – The risk assessment is one of the difficult tasks because BOT toll roads have complex
structure. In this study, total 71 risks have been identified and categorized under 14 risk factors on a
basis of case studies of Indian toll roads and literature review. All risks have been assessed by the fuzzy
probabilistic model by lab-view. The land acquisition is the most crucial risk of BOT toll roads project
which is subsequently followed by construction time and cost over-run. Also, Indian BOT toll roads are
facing the traffic shortfalls critically, which became a reason toward declination trend for investment in
BOT toll projects by the private players. Other risks like political risks, contractual and social risk
badly are affecting the project performance. Early risk identification and assessment can be beneficial
for the project, which is required to prepare the risk response strategy before the project
commencement.
Originality/value – This study throws light on comprehensive risk assessment and framework modeling
of the risk assessment for the BOT toll roads project in India. This comprehensive risk assessor model can be
used for BOT toll roads in Indian scenario for prioritization of the critical risk. It is important for the public
and private sectors to establish an effective risk assessor model for public–private partnership (PPP) projects
to achieve win-win condition for both.
Keywords India, Fuzzy logic, Risk assessment, Risk management,
Public private partnership (PPP), BOT toll road
Paper type Research paper
Assessment of
BOT toll roads
in Indian
context
251
Received 24 May 2019
Accepted 16 July 2019
Journal of Engineering, Design
and Technology
Vol. 18 No. 1, 2020
pp. 251-269
© Emerald Publishing Limited
1726-0531
DOI 10.1108/JEDT-05-2019-0138
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at:
https://www.emerald.com/insight/1726-0531.htm