Disclinations and Their Interactions in Thin Films of Side-Chain Liquid
Crystalline Polymers
Shanju Zhang, Eugene M. Terentjev, and Athene M. Donald*
Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, Madingley Road, CB3 0HE, Cambridge, UK
Received August 21, 2003; Revised Manuscript Received October 24, 2003
ABSTRACT: Two-dimensional disclinations formed in thin films of a side-chain liquid crystalline polymer
are investigated using transmission electron microscopy (TEM). The detailed director patterns are revealed
through nanoscale stripes, which are parallel to the molecular director. One hyperbolic pattern of a
negative disclination with a charge s )-1 and three patterns involving radial, circular, and spiral director
fields of a positive disclination with s )+1 are observed. Positive disclination cores are found to exhibit
circular dark centers while the s )-1 is shown to have a bright central core. The difference in TEM
contrast is attributed to the nature of the packing within the core. From the director texture around a
disclination it is possible to determine the elastic anisotropy, which is not higher than 0.1. Observing the
time evolution of the disclination density, it is found that the average number of defects in the plane
scales with time as N ∝ t
-3/4
. It is found that both translation and rotation motions occur for a pair of
(+1, -1) disclinations, leading to the formation of a certain special configuration shortly before the pair
annihilation. In some cases, not the pairs but the linear clusters of three-disclination dominate the
interaction. Theoretical analysis is presented to explain this new phenomenon. In addition, director
inversion walls are observed to form during the late stage of disclination annihilation. It is found that
inversion walls always separate a pair of (+1, +1) disclinations.
Introduction
Liquid crystals (LC) are characterized by a preferred
orientational order, which is described by an apolar
director n field. The most probable director configura-
tion is determined by minimization of the total free
energy with respect to the director field. In deformed
liquid crystals, disclinations are rotation symmetry-
breaking defects. The strength of a disclination corre-
sponds to the number of rotations of the director around
a path encircling the disclination.
1
Disclinations and
their interactions have been theoretically investigated
for many years.
2-5
Such experimental studies are
limited in scope in that most of them use optical
microscopy to study small molecular LCs or liquid
crystalline polymers (LCP’s).
4-7
The pairwise interaction
of disclinations is analogous to the electrostatic interac-
tion between line charges. The interaction forces are
inversely proportional to the distances. Disclinations of
opposite sign attract and annihilate each other, while
disclinations of the same sign repel each other. This
interaction leads to the annihilation of defects and hence
a decrease in their number density. The details of these
processes are, however, still far from being understood
due to both the complexity of potential many-body
disclination interactions and the lack of suitable, high-
resolution, experimental methods.
Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) is a useful
method for studying the microstructure at a molecular
level. It has proved to be of great utility in the study of
LCP’s over the past two decades.
8,9
In the case of
semicrystalline LCP’s, crystalline lamellae, which are
formed perpendicular to the local director, can be used
to decorate molecular orientation, and the director
trajectories around a disclination are, therefore, directly
visualized via TEM.
10,11
This technique to explore the
director orientation in semicrystalline LCP’s has been
successfully applied for the analysis of disclinations and
their interactions in main-chain LCP’s.
12-14
Hudson and
Thomas studied the structure around cores of half-
integer disclinations (charge s )(
1
/
2
) by analysis of the
elastic anisotropy.
15
They found that a rigid polymer
splayed more at the near-core, while a flexible polymer
bent more. Hudson and Thomas also studied disclina-
tion (s )(
1
/
2
) interactions in applied magnetic and
extensional flow fields.
16
They observed that a stable
four-body disclination cluster (a so-called Lehmann
cluster) dominated the interaction at weak and inter-
mediate field strengths. However, almost no observation
of director fields of disclinations in side-chain amor-
phous LCP’s systems has been reported to date.
17
Side-chain LCP’s present a unique class of materials
with mesomorphic and viscoelastic behavior.
18,19
Their
microstructures result from the delicate balance be-
tween liquid crystalline order due to the mesogenic core
and statistical disorder due to the polymer backbone
entropy. In side-chain LCP’s, the orientational proper-
ties are carried by the short mesogenic side chains, and
the nature of the order parameter is then similar to that
in small-molecule LC’s.
20
In contrast to main-chain
systems, there are many theoretical and experimental
indications that the values of Frank elastic constants
in side-chain LCP’s are close to those in analogous
small-molecule LC’s.
21,22
Therefore, the problems of
molecular packing are of a different nature in main-
chain and side-chain systems. Recently, we reported the
observation of two-dimensional nanoscale stripes in thin
films of a side-chain smectic polymer using TEM.
23
When the samples were cooled to the smectic phase,
after a holding period in the nematic phase, a charac-
teristic surface morphology developed. This morphology
manifested itself in bright field TEM images as a series
of nanostripes which aligned along the local director.
This orientation was demonstrated by correlating the
direction of the stripes with electron diffraction patterns. * Corresponding author.
390 Macromolecules 2004, 37, 390-396
10.1021/ma035240o CCC: $27.50 © 2004 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 12/18/2003