Journal of Agricultural Science, Cambridge (1996), 126, 441-448. © 1996 Cambridge University Press 441
General adaptability of potato genotypes selected in
the UK for the Mediterranean region
J. BROWN*, M. F. B. DALEf AND G. R. MACKAY
Scottish Crop Research Institute, Invergowrie, Dundee DD2 5DA, Scotland, UK
(Revised MS received 18 July 1995)
SUMMARY
The recombinant genotypes generated with a potato breeding scheme cannot always be evaluated
over the range of environments for which cultivar development is aimed. At the Scottish Crop
Research Institute, the cultivar breeding programme aims to develop genotypes which perform well
in one or more environments in the UK and/or countries around the Mediterranean basin. In each
of three years (1984, 1985 and 1986) between 40 and 50 potato genotypes were selected solely on their
phenotypic performance in an environment just south of Edinburgh in Scotland. These were then
trialled at sites in four environments in the typical ware-producing regions of England and four
environments around the Mediterranean region. Despite significant genotype x environment
interactions for many traits, the superior genotypes tended to perform well over a wide range of
environments.
INTRODUCTION
Genotype x environment interactions have been
recognized by plant breeders for many years (Hill
1975). It is therefore common practice in many crop
species to locate breeding stations in the region where
the resulting new cultivars will be grown in order that
selected genotypes will be better adapted to that
particular region. However, many regions grow
potato cultivars that were bred elsewhere. Potato
crops are grown in many diverse countries with
differing soil types, climates and daylengths, while
most breeding programmes are located in the northern
latitude countries of Europe and North America. The
reason for having the breeding programmes in these
areas is partly historical, but is also related to the
many disease problems which are often associated
with repeated vegetative multiplication. The potato is
affected by more diseases than is any other major
agricultural crop (Hind & Lapwood 1978). Most of
these diseases are transmitted by, or the inoculum
source derives from, the mother tuber to daughter
tubers. To avoid disease accumulating within breeding
stocks, potato breeders often carry out early gen-
eration selection under conditions which are markedly
different from the conditions which will exist in the
• Present address: Plant Science Division, Department of
Plant, Soil and Entomological Sciences, University of Idaho,
Moscow, Idaho 83844-2339, USA.
t To whom correspondence should be addressed.
areas at which resulting cultivars are targeted.
Consequently, the greatest selection pressure is often
exerted while potato genotypes are grown under
conditions conducive to high-grade seed production
(high altitude, northern latitude and short growing
seasons). The selected genotypes will not be tested
under typical ware (grown for consumption) con-
ditions until after the initial rounds of selection have
been carried out.
One objective of the SCRI potato programme is to
develop desirable genotypes for use by the UK potato
industry, both within the UK and also for export
overseas. Details of a modern breeding scheme are
given by Bradshaw & Mackay (1994). The present
study examined data from within such a breeding
programme to assess the consistency and efficiency of
selection within UK trial conditions and compared
these with results from the diverse environments
found in trials in the Mediterranean area. The results
presented here investigate the relationship between
adaptability and selection of material assessed in
three seasons in the UK (1984, 1985 and 1986) with
their adaptability when assessed in the subsequent
year in each of three seasons at four environments in
the Mediterranean region (1985, 1986 and 1987).
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Genotypes examined in this study were all derived
from the potato breeding programme at the Scottish
Crop Research Institute, involving a diverse range of