Quantifying the Short-Range Order in Amorphous Silicon by Raman
Scattering
Priyanka Yogi,
†
Manushree Tanwar,
†
Shailendra K. Saxena,*
,‡
Suryakant Mishra,
§
Devesh K. Pathak,
Anjali Chaudhary, Pankaj R. Sagdeo, and Rajesh Kumar*
Material Research Laboratory, Discipline of Physics & MEMS, Indian Institute of Technology Indore, Simrol-453552, India
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Quantification of the short-range order in amorphous silicon has
been formulized using Raman scattering by taking into account established
frameworks for studying the spectral line-shape and size dependent Raman peak
shift. A theoretical line-shape function has been proposed for representing the
observed Raman scattering spectrum from amorphous-Si-based on modified
phonon confinement model framework. While analyzing modified phonon
confinement model, the term “confinement size” used in the context of
nanocrystalline Si was found analogous to the short-range order distance in a-Si
thus enabling one to quantify the same using Raman scattering. Additionally, an
empirical formula has been proposed using bond polarizability model for
estimating the short-range order making one capable to quantify the distance of
short-range order by looking at the Raman peak position alone. Both the proposals
have been validated using three different data sets reported by three different
research groups from a-Si samples prepared by three different methods making the
analysis universal.
N
anoscience and nanotechnology has been established as
an important area, which makes it equally important to
characterize these materials which were considered amorphous
for long.
1,2
At the junction of the (poly-)crystalline and
amorphous, in a particular crystallite size window,
3,4
a size-
dependent property variation was observed, which marks the
domain of the nanoscience.
5,6
The length of ordered material
7
(in the crystallinity) remained the distinguishing parameter
between the three phases of solid,
8
crystalline,
9,10
nanocrystal-
line,
11
and amorphous,
12
with crystalline material having the
longest range of order of crystallinity, whereas amorphous
material
13
has the least. The distance up to which a (poly-
)crystalline solid maintains the crystallinity defines the degree
of order,
14
which is quantified by the crystallite size. Though
the crystallite size quantifies the degree of order in crystalline
materials, ambiguity remains inherently, while quantifying the
term in amorphous material as the range of the order is rather
“short” and usually not defined even empirically. Whereas, in
nanocrystalline materials the crystallite size comparable to the
Bohr’s radius
15,16
declares the onset of the “nano” regime and
can be defined as the distance of the range of order. Such kind
of quantification of the degree of order may prove to be of
scientific and technological importance and thus needs
attention. As an example, it is often observed that efficiency
of amorphous silicon (a-Si) solar cells
17,18
depends on the
method of material preparation though the actual player
responsible for this variation is unknown. It is possible to see a
correlation between the quantified short-range order and solar
cell efficiency thus will be helpful in designing an appropriate a-
Si device. Additionally, quantification of the short-range order
in amorphous materials may help in identifying any possible
scientific information in this gray area, which may lead to great
discoveries as in the case of nanoscience.
Presence of order, whether short-range or long-range, can be
examined by X-ray diffraction (XRD) qualitatively but can not
be quantified by this method. Raman scattering,
19-21
which has
been established as a widely used versatile spectroscopic tool,
may prove to be just appropriate for the purpose because of its
various scientific merits. The only disadvantage, being a weak
phenomenon, has been taken care of in the instrumentation
because of the availability of very good source and detectors
making it an unmatchable characterization tool used by
scientists across all the disciplines. Raman scattering is not
only a probe to study the phase identification,
22,23
chemical
compositions,
24,25
and level of doping
26,27
but it also has shown
a promising potential for acting as a sensitive probe to monitor
various physical phenomena taking place at microscopic levels,
such as confinement,
21,28-31
defect structures, and crystalline
nature of materials.
32
Because of its immense advantages and
broader acceptability, Raman spectroscopy has not lagged
behind even in understanding di fferent phenomena in
comparatively newer but exceptionally important field of
nanosciences and nanotechnology.
33,34
At times, Raman
spectroscopy has been proved to be superior to other methods
Received: March 26, 2018
Accepted: June 1, 2018
Article
pubs.acs.org/ac
Cite This: Anal. Chem. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX
© XXXX American Chemical Society A DOI: 10.1021/acs.analchem.8b01352
Anal. Chem. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX