Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Fluorine Chemistry
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ fluor
Synthesis, crystal structures, properties and caries prevention efficiency of
2-, 3-, 4-carboxymethylpyridinium hexafluorosilicates
Vladimir O. Gelmboldt
a
, Vladimir Yu. Anisimov
a
, Ivan O. Shyshkin
a
, Marina S. Fonari
b,
⁎
,
Victor Ch. Kravtsov
b
a
Odessa National Medical University, Odessa, Ukraine
b
Institute of Applied Physics Academy of Sciences of R. Moldova, Chisinau, Republic of Moldova
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Hexafluorosilicates
Pyridinium cations
Crystal structure
Hydrogen bonding
Solubility
Caries prevention efficiency
ABSTRACT
Three pyridinium hexafluorosilicates with the compositions (LH)
2
[SiF
6
](I, II, III, where L = 2-, 3-, 4-carbox-
ymethylpyridine) were obtained as crystalline solids upon interaction of hexafluorosilicic acid with isomeric
carboxymethylpyridines. All compounds were characterized by elemental analysis, IR, NMR
19
F and mass-
spectrometry, solubility data, and X-ray crystallography. The binary ionic solids are stabilized by the interplay of
intermolecular interactions including strong charge assisted and conventional hydrogen bonds of the NH⋯F, and
OH⋯O types along with CH⋯F contacts and π–π stacking interactions. The different supramolecular motifs in I-
III are dictated by the different arrangement of the principal binding sites in the isomeric carboxymethylpyr-
idines. The relationship between the salts structure and solubility data is discussed. All hexafluorosilicates re-
duce the depth and the number of dental caries, and provide efficiency of caries prevention up to 45%.
1. Introduction
Nowadays, the tooth decay is one of the most common diseases [1],
while for the childhood this pathology ranks first among chronic dis-
eases and has a pandemic character. In the arsenal of treatment and
prevention of caries, the key positions occupy inorganic fluorides, in-
cluding sodium and potassium fluorides, tin difluoride, sodium mono-
fluorophosphate, and silver diammine fluoride, [Ag(NH
3
)
2
]F (SDF) [2].
In recent years, researchers from Japan and the USA have announced
ammonium hexafluorosilicate, (NH
4
)
2
[SiF
6
] (AHF) as a promising
caries preventive agent [3–9]. Unlike SDF, AHF does not cause staining
of hard tooth tissues [10] and provides acid resistance of tooth enamel
and dentin [3], prolonged occlusion of tubul dentin [4], and increases
the crystallinity of tooth enamel [5,6]. The specificity of the action of
AHF as a caries prophylactic and hyposensitive agent is as follows: in
saliva (biological fluid) environment, AHF is hydrolyzed to form a so-
luble form of silica which catalyzes the precipitation of a mixture of
fluorapatite and calcium fluoride [4,7], and the formation of the crys-
talline precipitate stable in saliva. In principle, the effectiveness of the
anti-caries action of salts with the [SiF
6
]
2−
anion can be increased by
using hexafluorosilicates with biologically active “onium” cations. In
this case, it becomes possible to enhance the caries-preventive action of
the fluoride component as a result of specific (pharmacological, phy-
sicochemical) cation effects [11]. In particular, the search for new
potential anti-caries agents in the series of hexafluorosilicates whose
cations exhibit bactericidal and anti-inflammatory activity is important
in a complex of measures in the treatment and prevention of caries
[12,13].
This contribution is addressed to the synthesis, study of the struc-
ture, properties and caries prevention effect of 2-, 3-, 4-carbox-
ymethylpyridinium hexafluorosilicates, whose organic cations are ex-
pected to exhibit anti-inflammatory activity based on the PASS-
prognosis [14].
2. Results and discussion
2.1. Crystal structures
All compounds were obtained by interaction of relevant N-base with
hexafluorosilicic acid in aqueous solution. Crystal structure and re-
finement data for I–III are given in Table 1, hydrogen bonding geo-
metry is summarized in Table 2. The formula units for I-III are shown in
Fig. 1. Compounds I–III have the 1:2 acid : base ratio and crystallize in
the monoclinic centrosymmetric space groups P2
1
/n (I), P2
1
/c (II), and
I2/a (III) with the [SiF
6
]
2−
anion occupying positions on inversion
centers in I, II and on a two-fold axis in III. On the molecular level, the
changes in the geometry of components are identical to those pre-
viously reported for the related hexafluorosilicates, since the proton
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfluchem.2017.11.004
Received 13 October 2017; Received in revised form 13 November 2017; Accepted 15 November 2017
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: fonari.xray@phys.asm.md (M.S. Fonari).
Journal of Fluorine Chemistry 205 (2018) 15–21
Available online 16 November 2017
0022-1139/ © 2017 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T