Open Access. © 2021 Y. Yildirim and M. Aref, published by De Gruyter. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons
Attribution 4.0 License
Noise Mapp. 2021; 8:108ś115
Research Article
Yalcin Yildirim* and Mahyar Aref
Noise complaints during a pandemic:
A longitudinal analysis
https://doi.org/10.1515/noise-2021-0008
Received Dec 14, 2020; accepted Jan 28, 2021
Abstract: COVID-19 has afected people’s lives in diferent
ways from reduced mobility and staying-at-home orders
to other daily life routines. These changes have, in turn,
afected the quality of life in urban environments including
air quality and noise. The noise aspect, for example, sug-
gests quieter environments due to fewer vehicles on streets,
and less human activities. On the other hand, staying at
home may cause more activities happening at the build-
ing level, i.e., more people in buildings may make more
noise for neighbors. In order to understand this nexus, the
study examines the noise complaints data in Dallas, USA.
To do this, the study frst compares the noise complaints
after the COVID-19 intercourse and the same data period in
2019. Findings surprisingly show reduced noise complaints
during the COVID-19 time frame by about 14% compared
to the pre-COVID-19 period. The majority of this reduction
occurred in and around the city center. In other words, the
noise complaints seem more spatially dispersed at the out-
skirts of the city. Another fnding that directs more detailed
analyses, however, considers the massive reduction of rid-
ership, trafc circulation, and building permits. This needs
some other techniques for determining the sources for in-
commensurate noise complaints.
Keywords: COVID-19, noise complaints, 311 data, city center,
suburbs
1 Introduction
Once ofcially identifed, the frst COVID-19 case in China
rapidly spread all over the world. With the frst case re-
ported on January 20
th
, the government declared a public
health emergency at the end of January 2020. An immediate
application of a number of international restrictions and
*Corresponding Author: Yalcin Yildirim: Bursa Technical Univer-
sity, Department of Landscape Architecture, Bursa, 16310, Turkey;
Email: yalcin.yildirim@btu.edu.tr
Mahyar Aref: Jundi Shapur Technical University, Dezful, Iran
controls ensued national-level actions, including testing
and travel restrictions. After announcing the strict COVID
Act in March 2020, though the U.S. did not mandate lock-
down, regional and local ofcials considered several reac-
tions, i.e., canceling large gatherings, stay at home orders,
and school closures.
Fewer commutes as well as reduced outdoor human
activities and witnessing new urban lifestyles, travel behav-
iors, and home-bound adaptations were associated with
other observations such as the cleaner air quality, and noise
reduction in the built environment. Staying at home al-
lows people to have more time for various activities such
as watching TV, listening to’ loud music, workout activ-
ities, home repairing, kids’ play, etc. Thus, while trafc-
related and other outdoor anthropogenic activities may re-
duce noise complaints, staying at home may increase other
forms of noise. Consequently, the prolonged COVID-19 era
has stimulated noise complaints for various reasons. In
order to understand the direct linkage between COVID-19
and noise complaint requests, this study has culled and
analyzed them from March through December 2020, and
has compared the same sourced noise complaints with the
same period last year.
2 Related studies
2.1 COVID-19 and Noise
Several studies have examined the relationship between
the unpredicted COVID-19 outbreak and noise from various
aspects. Perhaps as a pioneer study in examining noise dur-
ing the COVID-19, Aletta et al. created a trafc simulation
that represented noise pollution in Rome, Italy [1]. Their
fndings report almost 65% reduction in both trafc and
noise emissions during the lockdown [1]. Pagès et al.’s [2]
study in the same location and Milan examined the efects
of the COVID-19 on trafc and non-trafc noise activities by
using the DYNAMAP system. To do this, the authors com-
pared the same noise events in the same period of time
in 2019. Aletta et al. [3] collected soundscape assessments
from 11 locations in London before the 2019 lockdown, and