PAPER www.rsc.org/pps | Photochemical & Photobiological Sciences
Can subpyriporphyrin and its boron complex be proposed as photosensitizers
in photodynamic therapy? A first principle time dependent study
Ida Lanzo, Angelo D. Quartarolo, Nino Russo and Emilia Sicilia
Received 8th October 2008, Accepted 5th January 2009
First published as an Advance Article on the web 16th January 2009
DOI: 10.1039/b817718j
Density functional theory (DFT) and its time-dependent approach (TDDFT) in conjunction with the
PBE0 exchange–correlation functional have been employed to characterize the structural and electronic
properties of a new synthesized homologue of a triphyrin, in which a pyrrole ring has been substituted
with a pyridine moiety, and its boron complex. Absorption spectra have been computed for different
isomers of the free compound as well as for the corresponding boron containing system. The solvent
effects have been evaluated through the polarizable continuum model (PCM). Triplet energies have been
computed in order to verify whether these systems should be proposed as photosensitizers in
photodynamic therapy. Results show that the employed tool is able to correctly reproduce the
absorption spectra and to contribute to better assign the electronic transitions explaining their origin
and that the examined boron complex has a triplet energy that, in principle, can activate the singlet O
2
reactive species.
1. Introduction
The porphyrins and their expanded ring analogues are the most
studied macrocyclic ring systems since their peculiar electronic
structures give rise to numerous properties that make these systems
particularly interesting in a wide range of applications going from
nonlinear optics, to photonic devices, to dye technologies.
1–3
Less
effort has been devoted to synthesize and characterize contracted
porphyrinoids such as subphtalocyanines,
4,5
subporphyrazines
6,7
tribenzosubporphyrins
8,9
and subporphyrins
10,11
that contain three
pyrrole or isoindole moieties. Contrary to porphyrins and their
expanded ring analogues, these systems comprise a 14-p-electron
aromatic core, often adopt a nonplanar conformation and con-
sequently reveal very interesting spectral and electronic features
4
potentially useful for their application in many fields of modern
technologies. The absorbance spectra in the UV/Vis region of
the subporphyrinoids are blue-shifted with respect to the more
expanded porphyrin-like systems due to their small p-conjugated
cores and are intensively coloured from orange to deep red. These
characteristics make them potential candidates in high-density
optical data storage technology.
4
Recently, subpyriporphyrin,
hereafter denoted SPP (see Scheme 1), which is a novel type
of contracted porphyrin, a homologue of [14]thriphyrin(1.1.1) in
which one pyrrole ring has been substituted with a pyridine moiety,
has been synthesized as a free ligand and as a boron containing
complex.
10
The absorption spectra of these new compounds are
interesting and contain transitions in both B and Q bands. The
reported UV/Vis absorption spectra
10
are not well assigned and
the origin of the electronic transitions are not known.
Since the considered systems show transition energies in the Q
band (greater than 500 nm), in principle they should be active
in photodynamic therapy (PDT). This non-invasive therapy is
Dipartimento di Chimica and Centro di Calcolo ad Alte Prestazioni
per Elaborazioni Parallele e Distribuite-Centro d’Eccellenza MURST,
Universita’ della Calabria, I-87030, Arcavacata di Rende, (CS), Italy
currently used for the treatment of a variety of diseases in oncology,
but is explored also in the areas of cardiology, ophthalmology, der-
matology, immunology, gynaecology, urology
12–15
and microbial
infections.
16
In PDT a non-toxic photosensitizer is introduced in the body
of the appropriate target and is irradiated with a wavelength light
ranging from 600 to 900 nm (the so-called therapeutic window), in
order to excite the photosensitizer from its ground state (S
0
) in a
short-lived first excited state (S
1
). Furthermore, S
1
can undergo
conversion to the first excited triplet state (T
1
) by intersystem
crossing. Then the T
1
state of the sensitizer can release its energy
to the surrounding biological tissue, exciting the O
2
from its triplet
(
3
R
g
) to the highly reactive singlet state (
1
D
g
) that induces an
oxidative cellular damage leading to the apoptosis or necrosis of
the cells.
In order to contribute to give further insights into the origin of
these transitions, to better characterize the optical spectra of these
new synthesized macrocycles and to verify whether their electronic
properties are interesting for their possible use in PDT, we have
undertaken a systematic study of the structure and electronic
properties of different isomers of the free species as well as of
their boron complexes (see Scheme 1).
2. Computational method
The study has been performed at density functional (DF) level
of theory and employing its time dependent extension (TD-
DFT).
17
Full geometry optimization for each studied free lig-
and and corresponding boron complex has been carried out
using the Turbomole program
18
employing the PBE0
19
exchange–
correlation functional and the SVP and TZVP all electron basis
sets.
20
The PBE0 functional, based on the generalized gradient
functional PBE
20
with 25% exact exchange, has been chosen
as it generally reproduces geometrical parameters, including in
metal containing systems, within experimental error.
19
As recently
386 | Photochem. Photobiol. Sci., 2009, 8, 386–390 This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and Owner Societies 2009