This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY 1
Interfacing -Factor Based White-Box Transformer
Models With Electromagnetic Transients Programs
Bjørn Gustavsen, Fellow, IEEE, and Álvaro Portillo, Senior Member, IEEE
Abstract—White-box transformer models are used by trans-
former manufacturers during the dielectric design of windings.
The models are often based on constant parameters (RLCG ma-
trices) with the high-frequency losses accounted for by a scaling
of the dc resistance ( -Factor). We show an efficient procedure
for interfacing such models with Electromagnetic Transients
Program (EMTP)-type circuit simulators via state equations and
a Norton equivalent. The approach makes no approximations
except for the discretization in the time domain. Diagonalization is
utilized for achieving high computational efficiency. Proprietary
information about internal voltages is optionally hidden from the
user. Internal surge arresters are handled by the EMTP circuit
solver by declaring their connection points as external nodes. The
model interface includes automated initialization from 50/60-Hz
initial conditions. The proposed interfacing capability permits
manufacturers to apply their models in complete network simula-
tions, and to share their models with users.
Index Terms—Electromagnetic Transients Program (EMTP),
simulation, transformer, white-box model.
I. INTRODUCTION
P
OWER transformers have, in several instances, suf-
fered dielectric failure with overvoltages as a suspected
cause, even when normal practices for insulation coordination
and protection have been followed. CIGRE formed in 2008
Working Group (WG) A2/C4.39 “Electrical transient inter-
action between transformers and the power system” with the
objective to clarify the underlying reason for such failures and if
possible recommend procedures for avoiding their occurrence.
One of the major conclusions from that work is the observation
that oscillating overvoltages of relatively low amplitudes that
impinge the transformer terminals can result in excessive
overvoltages inside the transformer’s windings by resonance
as has also been documented in a number of past studies [1].
The Working Group further recommends that the manufacturer
should, by request from the customer, provide a terminal
equivalent (black-box) model to permit the user to calculate
the impinging overvoltages at the transformer terminals using
EMTP-type circuit solvers. The impinging overvoltages can
Manuscript received September 18, 2013; revised February 03, 2014; ac-
cepted June 19, 2014. Paper no. TPWRD-01070-2013.
B. Gustavsen is with SINTEF Energy Research, Trondheim N-7465, Norway
(e-mail: bjorn.gustavsen@sintef.no).
Á. Portillo is with WEG Transformers, Blumenau SC 89068-001, Brazil
(e-mail: acport@adinet.com.uy).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRD.2014.2332515
then be used by the manufacturer as input for calculating in-
ternal overvoltages using its proprietary (white-box) software.
That way, modifications can be made to the adjacent power
system and/or transformer design to reduce the probability of
future failures.
The white-box models can be categorized as lumped circuit
models based on a spatial discretization of the windings, or trav-
eling wave-type models. The extraction of the model’s parame-
ters is, in all cases, based on a detailed description of the trans-
former’s geometry and material properties which, in practice,
are only known to the manufacturer. From this information, the
model’s parameters are extracted via formulae and/or finite-el-
ement method computations. Several levels of refinement are
possible, including frequency dependency of the model’s pa-
rameters as well as the resolution of the spatial discretization.
In this paper, we demonstrate how to employ the recom-
mended procedure by A2/C4.39 in practice. We consider the
case of lumped-parameter white-box models based on constant
RLCG parameters, commonly applied among manufacturers.
Damping effects are included in the model by applying a con-
stant multiplier factor ( -Factor) to all dc resistances. (One may
alternatively calculate the resistances at a given, representative
frequency.) Based on these matrices, we formulate a model
in terms of state equations with current injection from ground
to all nodes as input and internal node voltages and branch
voltages as output. Next, we develop a computational approach
for interfacing this model with EMTP-type circuit solvers,
based on convolution and a Norton equivalent. The terminals of
the Norton equivalent may include transformer internal nodes
for the connection of internal surge arresters. Internal node
voltages and branch currents are made available for monitoring
as well. Diagonalization is introduced for faster simulations
and hiding of proprietary information. Automated initialization
from 50/60-Hz steady initial conditions is introduced, assuming
the model has sufficiently accurate behavior at that frequency.
We show one procedure for enforcing correct 50/60-Hz model
behavior for single-phase transformers by introducing the
magnetic core flux path in the inductance matrix. Finally, we
show a number of pertinent examples demonstrating the new
approach to the so-called “Fictitious Transformer” used in the
studies by CIGRE Working Group A2/C4.39 [2].
II. WHITE-BOX MODELING
A. Lumped Parameter Transformer White-Box Models
White-box models are used for analyzing the internal re-
sponse of the power transformer to a system voltage transient
applied to its terminals. In the lumped parameter modeling
0885-8977 © 2014 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.