CORROSION SCIENCE
546 CORROSION–JULY 1994
✫
Submitted for publication October 1993; in revised form, January 1994.
Presented as paper no. 005 at the 12th International Corrosion Congress,
September 1993, Houston, TX.
* Bethlehem Steel Corp., Homer Research Laboratories, Bethlehem, PA,
18016.
** Air Products and Chemicals Inc., 7201 Hamilton Blvd., Allentown, PA,
18195.
Structure of Rust on Weathering Steel
in Rural and Industrial Environments
✫
H.E. Townsend, T.C. Simpson,* and G.L. Johnson**
ABSTRACT
Rust on weathering steels exposed for up to 11 y in industrial
and rural environments exhibited a spotty, nonuniform
appearance as a result of contrast between light and dark
areas on the surface. The area of the lighter regions
increased with exposure time, as well as with increasing alloy
content. Microscopic examination of cross sections revealed
the dark regions had a porous appearance. The lighter
regions were similar except for the presence of a relatively
thin, smooth outer-surface layer. Raman spectroscopy
indicated the dark, porous rust was comprised of goethite and
lepidocrocite, while the smooth outer layer on the light areas
was composed of hematite (-Fe
2
O
3
) and magnetite (Fe
3
O
4
).
Electrochemical potential measurements indicated the lighter
areas were more passive. Results suggested formation of the
thin outer layer of -Fe
2
O
3
and Fe
3
O
4
is an important part of
the mechanism of protective rust formation on weathering
steels in the environments studied.
KEY WORDS: A588 steel, A242 steel, goethite, hematite,
industrial environment, lepidocrocite, magnetite, potential,
Raman spectroscopy, rural environment, rust, weathering
steels
INTRODUCTION
The term “weathering steels” describes a class of low-
alloy steels with enhanced resistance to atmospheric
corrosion. Although the underlying mechanisms are
not understood completely, it is well known that
alloying elements such as copper (Cu), chromium (Cr),
nickel (Ni), phosphorus (P), and silicon (Si) somehow
promote formation of protective rust layers during
outdoor exposure. Weathering steels generally contain
a combination of these elements totaling < ~ 3 wt%.
Because of barrier protection imparted by the
protective rust layers, weathering steels are used
outdoors without paint or other protective coatings.
Corrosion testing of weathering steel for up to 16 y in a
variety of environments has been reported previously.
1
However, certain environmental conditions may be
unfavorable for development of protective rust on
weathering steel. According to United States
government guidelines, the following conditions
should be avoided: high levels of salt (chloride
> 0.5 mg/100 cm
2
/day), high wetness times (average
time of wetness > 60%), and direct exposure to high
levels of industrial pollutants (i.e., sulfur trioxide
> 2.1 mg/100 cm
2
/day).
2
Unpainted weathering steels
have been used successfully in applications such as
bridges, utility towers, and highway guardrails when
these guidelines have been followed.
During long-term corrosion tests, the rust layers on
weathering steel exposed at rural and industrial test
0010-9312/94/000125/$5.00+$0.50/0
© 1994, NACE International