Short report 163
Should the general practitioner be prepared for the patient
with decreased consciousness or coma?
Jan Matthys
a
, Walter Buylaert
b
, Peter De Paepe
b
, Anke Thoen
a
,
Jean-Pierre Matthijs
c
and An De Sutter
a
Background Data are scarce about the possible role for
the general practitioner (GP) in patients with decreased
consciousness (DC) or coma. We wanted to investigate
how often a GP is confronted with DC or coma during
out-of-hours service in an urban region and to compare the
patients presented to primary care to those who were
immediately treated by the emergency medical services
(EMS).
Method In a prospective observational study during 2
weekends in the city of Ghent, Belgium, which has 232 500
inhabitants, 724 patients were seeking emergency care,
and DC or coma was the reason for encounter in 27
patients (3.8%). Eight patients initially seen by a GP had
more heterogeneous diagnoses than the 19 patients
immediately transferred to the emergency department
without intervention by a GP.
Results and conclusion This study shows that about
one-third (N = 8) of emergencies involving patients with
DC or coma were initially evaluated by a GP; five out of
these eight patients were subsequently transported by the
EMS. We conclude that telephone triage guidelines providing
simultaneous alerts of the GP and the EMS for DC or coma
patients, tailored training of GPs with skills maintenance,
adequate equipment and close collaboration with the EMS
are recommended for GP out-of-hours services. European
Journal of Emergency Medicine 16:163–165
c
2009 Wolters
Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
European Journal of Emergency Medicine 2009, 16:163–165
Keywords: coma, epidemiology, general practice, guideline, loss of
consciousness, triage
Departments of
a
General Practice and Primary Health Care,
b
Emergency
Medicine, Ghent University and
c
Ghent Association of General Practitioners,
Ghent, Belgium
Correspondence to Jan Matthys, MD, Department of General Practice and
Primary Health Care, Ghent University, De Pintelaan 185, Ghent 9000, Belgium
Tel: +32 9 332 33 12; fax: +32 9 332 49 67;
e-mail: jan.matthys@ugent.be
Received 2 June 2008 Accepted 4 October 2008
Introduction
The role of the general practitioner (GP) in patients with
decreased consciousness (DC) or coma is often limited to
arranging a prompt transfer to the hospital by the
emergency medical services (EMS). Their handling of
these calls and the collaboration with the EMS in the field
is, however, of utmost importance for the patient. In this
study, we describe the incidence and causes of DC or coma
in calls for primary care in an urban region and compare the
patients presenting to primary care to those who were
transferred to the EMS without intervention of a GP.
Methods
We carried out a prospective study from Saturday 1200 h
to Sunday 1200 h during two consecutive weekends in
January 2006 in Ghent, Belgium. During this time period,
urgent medical help was accessible either through
primary medical care service by dialling a unique
nine-digit telephone number or through the unique
number 100 of the EMS with transport by ambulance
or mobile intensive care unit of the patient to one of the
four emergency departments in the city of Ghent. Each
of the services participated in the study. All patients
presenting to the primary medical care service of GPs and
to the EMS were included.
At the GP call centre, when a telephone call for a possible
life-threatening emergency arrived, the ambulance and
mobile intensive care unit could immediately be solicited.
All other calls were handled by one of the 36 GPs involved
in the out-of-hours service. The individual patient
characteristics, the reason for contact and a provisional
diagnosis of all patients seen by the GPs were collected
during a telephone call by a doctor in vocational training
on the same day of the patient contact. Furthermore,
the GPs provided a written report about the tentative
diagnosis and hospital referral (Tables 1 and 2). Results
are expressed as mean ± standard deviation (SPSS Inc.,
Chicago, Illinois, USA; version 12).
Results
During the study period, 724 patients sought medical
care: 437 patients were seen at the emergency
department and 287 patients were first evaluated by
a GP. DC or coma was present in 19 (4.3%) patients
presenting to the emergency department, and in eight
0969-9546 c 2009 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins DOI: 10.1097/MEJ.0b013e32831ceff2
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.