Paper
TRANSURANIC ISOTOPES AND
90
Sr IN ATTIC DUST IN THE
VICINITY OF TWO NUCLEAR ESTABLISHMENTS IN
NORTHERN GERMANY
I. Schmitz-Feuerhake,* J. W. Mietelski,
†
and P. Gaca
†
Abstract—Attic dust was chosen as the test medium in order to
search for traces of man-made bone seeking alpha and beta
emitters. The samples were taken from 5 houses in the
community of Elbmarsch situated at the river Elbe, adjacent to
the Krümmel nuclear power plant and the nuclear research
center of Geesthacht. Five houses in other regions of northern
Germany were taken as a control.
238
Pu,
239,240
Pu,
241
Am, and
244
Cm were measured by alpha spectrometry after chemical
separation. Additionally,
241
Pu was measured by liquid scintil-
lation spectrometry, and the fission product
90
Sr was measured
in a separate investigation. All nuclides except
244
Cm showed
activities above the detection limit in the Elbmarsch samples
and an elevated mean concentration compared to the control.
It can be concluded from the activity ratio
241
Am/
239,240
Pu that
the Elbmarsch contamination cannot be accounted for by the
background levels of transuranic nuclides resulting from
weapons fallout. The derived release of alpha emitters is
assumed to have contributed to the induction of a leukemia
cluster in children, which was observed in Elbmarsch between
1990 and 1996.
Health Phys. 84(5):599 – 607; 2003
Key words: environmental impact;
241
Am; inhalation; leuke-
mia
INTRODUCTION
THE COMMUNITY of Elbmarsch consists of a chain of
several small villages located at the southern bank of the
river Elbe, about 35 km southeast of Hamburg. In 1990,
a leukemia cluster appeared in children living there
(Hoffmann et al. 1997). Most cases up to now occurred
in the village Tespe, lying opposite to the nuclear
research center Gesellschaft fu ¨r Kernenergieverwertung
in Schiffbau und Schiffahrt (GKSS), established in 1958
(Fig. 1). West of GKSS, at a distance of about 1.5 km, a
nuclear power plant named Kernkraftwerk Kru ¨mmel
(KKK) began full operation in 1984. It is equipped by a
1,300 MWel boiling-water reactor.
The primary initial project of the GKSS was re-
search and development on the harnessing of nuclear
power for commercial ships. In the eighties, the center
was engaged in several research programs on nuclear
reactor safety and the development of components for
nuclear power plants. It was equipped with two nuclear
research reactors of 5 and 15 MW capacities.
In 1990, about 1,500 children under the age 15 y
lived in the Elbmarsch community. According to the
Childhood Cancer Registry for West Germany, one
leukemia case would have been expected there in 15 y.
However, five cases appeared between 1990 to 1991.
Four additional cases occurred by 1996 in the 5-km area
surrounding KKK. In the period 1990 to 1996, the
incidence of childhood leukemia in that region was
elevated by a factor of 5.6 (Schmitz-Feuerhake et al.
1997). All affected children were less than 11 y old at
time of the diagnosis, and five were below 5 y of age.
Because of the temporal correspondence between
the start-up of KKK and the appearance of the leukemia
cases—regarding known latencies for radiation-induced
malignancy—the suspicion arose that non-permitted
emissions of the plant might be responsible for the
induction of the diseases. The supervising ministry,
however, claimed undisturbed operation for KKK, the
two research reactors, and the experimental facilities of
GKSS and denied any relevant environmental contami-
nation.
Analyses of the environmental monitoring data were
also carried out by members of an expert committee,
officially appointed to identify possible causes of the
observed health effect. They registered several increases
of fission and activation products between 1984 and
1990 (Schmitz-Feuerhake et al. 1996; Schmidt et al.
1998). Biological dosimetry for 21 adults living in
Elbmarsch showed a significant elevation of dicentric
chromosomes (Schmitz-Feuerhake et al. 1997).
* University of Bremen, Department of Physics, PO Box 330440,
28209 Bremen, Germany;
†
The Henryk Niewodniczan ˜ski-Institute of
Nuclear Physics, Radzikowskiego 152, 31-342 Krako ´w, Poland.
For correspondence or reprints contact: I. Schmitz-Feuerhake,
Parkallee 87, Bremen 28209, Germany, or email at ingesf@
uni-bremen.de.
(Manuscript received 8 March 2002; revised manuscript received
19 September 2002, accepted 10 December 2002)
0017-9078/03/0
Copyright © 2003 Health Physics Society
599