A theoretical approach to zwitterionic
derivatives of 4-vinylpyridine
R. Salcedo, J. Cardoso, O. Manero and V. M. Monroy
Instituto de Investigaciones en Materiales, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de M#xico,
A. Postal 70-360, 04510 M~xico DF, Mexico
and J. L. V. Escobar and M. F. Rubio-Arroyo
Instituto de Quimica, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de M#xico, Circuito Exterior,
04510 M&xico DF, Mexico
(Received 15 August 1988; revised 7 November 1988; accepted 2 January 1989)
4-Vinylpyridineand a quaternized derivativewere calculated by the modifiedneglect of differentialoverlap
(MNDO) method to obtain values related to their geometry, energetic magnitudes and dipole moments
for the closed-shell molecules and the corresponding free radicals. A discussion of the chemical behaviour
of all structures is presented and some evidence for a possible free-radical pathway for polymerization is
analysed.
(Keywords: 4-vinylpyridine; MNDO method; zwitterion; quaternization; free radicals; polymerization)
INTRODUCTION
Monosubstituted pyridines are organic bases with known
nucleophilic properties and, most importantly, they have
a strong tendency to polymerize ~-3. Zwitterionic
derivatives of 4-vinylpyridine may produce polymers with
real charges, with interesting properties that include an
increase in ionic strength in aqueous solution4. In
addition, a number of molecular characteristics make
them particularly interesting as surfactants or detergents.
Pyridinic derivatives often have a complicated
chemical structure, with active sites where polymerization
may take place. It is therefore important to predict
theoretically the more feasible pathway of the polymer-
ization reaction, if specific characteristics of conformation
and stability of the final products (macromolecules) are
sought. Prediction of possible reaction mechanisms is
valuable in experimental characterization as well.
Vinylpyridine isomers have been studied in relation to
their base strength in both gas phase and solution4, with
further attention given to their chemical characteristics 5.
As Barone et al. 5 pointed out, the conformational
characteristics of conjugated molecules are determined
by a balance between steric and conjugative effects
(double bonds conjugated to aromatic rings), and this
kind of analysis represents one of the most difficult tasks
for semiempirical methods. Moreover, the zwitterionic
derivatives obtained after quaternization of the vinyl-
pyridine group are larger molecules where straight-
forward computations by more reliable ab initio methods
are extremely expensive. In the present investigation,
attention is given to a carboxylic derivative of
4-vinylpyridine obtained after quaternization, by using
the locally modified version of the MNDO method. These
calculations included total optimization of the molecular
structures of the closed-shell molecules and of the free
radicals produced in the polymerization process. The
program was computed on a 7800 Burroughs computer
using standard parameters 6.
CLOSED-SHELL MOLECULAR CALCULATIONS
In this section we address results of the calculations
corresponding to 4-vinylpyridine and the carboxylic
derivative obtained after the quaternization reaction:
H H
\ I
C=C
H +lO~C~ 2
N CHz-- CH2
4 - vinylpyridine
+ /~- loctone
LX~
H H
\ I
C= C\
N,
I
CH 2
I carboxybetaine
/c%
O_ 0
The relevant geometrical parameters and net charges
for 4-vinylpyridine and the quaternized molecule are
shown in Figures 1-3. Calculations in Figure 3 considered
a planar position of the vinyl group with respect to the
aromatic ring. This equilibrium structure corresponds to
the minimum energy or maximum stability of the
compound molecule 5. These results show that the
negative charge expected on the carboxylic group is split
over the two oxygen atoms, but the positive charge on
the nitrogen atom is not localized, due to the aromaticity
of the ring in the quaternized derivative. These results
also show that the distribution of the nitrogen charge
over the ring causes the reactivity of this atom to be
lower than expected. As a consequence, enhanced
reactivity is induced on the carbon and hydrogen atoms
of the ring. In addition, the first carbon atom of the vinyl
group shows a small negative value in both cases but it
is slightly larger in the quaternized molecule.
Another interesting aspect related to the chemical
properties of the quaternized molecule lies in the possible
sites for nucleophilic and electrophilic reactions. The two
0032-3861/89/0917474)4503.00
© 1989 Butterworth & Co. (Publishers) Ltd. POLYMER, 1989, Vol 30, September 1747